Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


10 July 2004

Stun gun doubts

From Vid Beldavs, Citizens for a Crisis Intervention Program

Our citizens' group has been tracking taser abuse across the US following the death of James Borden after tasering in our local jail on 6 November 2003. Our review of dozens of incidents reveals many cases where neither the officer nor the public were threatened. The taser has become the weapon of choice for bullying …

10 July 2004

Barks in the forest

From Howard Reid

Readers may be interested in anthropological evidence for extremely subtle human interpretations of dogs' barks (12 June, p 52) . The highly mobile Native South Americans collectively known as Maku hunt extensively with dogs in the forests of the Upper Rio Negro and the Vaupes region of Colombia and Brazil. Their dogs signal the species …

10 July 2004

Dubious detox

From Galen Ives

You may be interested in my experience of the Aqua Detox machine (Feedback, 19 June) . I was seeing a physiotherapist, and she offered me a course of treatment with this new cure-all. One look at the leaflet triggered my fruitcake detector, so the opportunity to test it at first hand was irresistible. The machine …

10 July 2004

Letter

From Peter Thomkins

Let's just suppose that the person operating the Aqua Detox device adds some unspecified salt to the water in the machine, as www.aquadetoxusa.com recommends. To get those "before and after" pictures, you need add nothing more exotic than common salt. An electric current passing through this salty water will make the electrodes rust, if they …

10 July 2004

Bearing jewels

From David Singer

Colin Finch's theory on why CD jewel cases are so called is certainly imaginative and possibly even convincing, but sadly incorrect (19 June, p 31) . Jewel cases get their name from two small plastic bumps, or bearings, that the cover hinges on. The practice of using real jewels as bearings in watches and clocks …

10 July 2004

Don't blame retardant

From Raymond B. Dawson, Bromine Science and Environment Forum

Fred Pearce's article "Flame retardant shows up in Arctic" wrongly assumes that there is a lack of scientific data on the flame retardant deca-BDE (12 June, p 10) . It does not mention that after 10 years of scientific analysis and more than 100 studies, a scientific assessment by the European Union could find no …

10 July 2004

Cool combustion

From Ravi Nadkarni

John Griffiths explains clearly the benefits of cool-flame combustion (5 June, p 28) . But low-temperature combustion must decrease the Carnot efficiency. This theoretical maximum efficiency for converting heat into mechanical energy is determined solely by the temperature difference between heat source and sink. Typical combustion temperatures for an engine using cool-flame ignition may be …

10 July 2004

Sofa and no further

From Bob Cowley

It has been widely reported that a meteorite crashed through the roof of a house in New Zealand and rebounded off the sofa, making a second hole in the ceiling (19 June, p 12) . Wait a minute. This rock hurtled around space for 4.5 billion years, before heading towards Earth at around 50,000 kilometres …

10 July 2004

Fido's feelings

From Andrea Stevenson

If humanity is defined by an ability to love, empathise, feel guilt and embarrassment, and understand deception and cooperation (19 June, p 32) then dogs are human! I thought so (as do they).

10 July 2004

Avian togetherness

From Paul Langford

The article on birds flocking refers to them "flying in one great and inexplicable mass" (26 June, p 48) . It seems to me that it has (since) been explained as emergent group behaviour built on very simple individual behaviour following these rules: 1. Keep together. 2. But not too close. 3. Follow the one …

10 July 2004

Tiny engine, big noise

From Shaun Walsh

Your article on the use of miniature internal combustion engines as power sources for portable electronic equipment leaves some questions unanswered (19 June, p 26) . For example: how do you prevent excessive wear over the lifetime of the power source? Most commonly used lubricants produce some exhaust residues and need to be delivered to …

10 July 2004

Radio daze

From Ron Petch

I agree that software bloat is a pain (19 June, p 30) . In the good old days, I could twiddle a knob and see the radio tuning in. Now I just have to assume that the setting is optimal.

Issue no. 2455 published 10 July 2004

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop