Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


1 April 2009

Mind or body?

From Charles Shepherd, The ME Association

It is unfortunate that Simon Wessely, interviewed in the article "Mind over body?" (14 March, p 26) , attaches a psychosomatic label to chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and, by implication, myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME). This inaccurate label not only creates practical problems for patients, such as inappropriate or harmful treatments and refusal of state benefits, it …

1 April 2009

Hacking the planet

From Gregory Benford, University of California, Irvine

Catherine Brahic's article on geoengineering (28 February, p 8) includes an account by James Fleming of a meeting I attended at NASA's Ames Research Center in California in November 2006. To clarify, at that meeting I advocated working through the Arctic Council to carry out field experiments, not the UN – and as an experiment …

1 April 2009

Back to Lagrange

From Laurence Taff

Reading your article on the possibility of observing the contents of Lagrangian points (21 February, p 30) reminded me of work I carried out in the mid-1970s. At that time, I initiated what is now termed the Lincoln Near-Earth Asteroid Research (LINEAR) project. It was the first search to use computer-controlled telescopes, television (and later, …

1 April 2009

Time flies

From Alex Jones

Unlike Tony Johnson (14 March, p 25), I can't accept that approximate number sense influences our perception that time accelerates as we get older. Rather, it seems to me, it has to do with the flow of information. Have you ever noticed how the first few days of a holiday go really slowly, and then …

1 April 2009

The red ape paradox

From Rolf Beilharz, University of Melbourne

Elaine Morgan reminds us that orang-utans are phenotypically more similar to humans than other apes, even though chimpanzees are genetically closest (7 March, p 26) . The explanation for this lies in the resource allocation paradigm of quantitative genetics, and the idea that it is not genes that are naturally selected in each generation, but …

1 April 2009

Reliable evidence

From Robert Matthews

Linda Geddes's sobering report about the reliability of forensic evidence highlights an important scientific issue: the need to establish error rates for any putative source of evidence (28 February, p 6) . Evidential weight depends on more than just the false negative rate – that is, the proportion of cases where the test fails to …

1 April 2009

En fin

From Jonathan Wallace

Caroline Williams's article on the worldwide decline in commercial fish stocks (7 March, p 40) made for depressing, if not surprising reading. One aspect she neglected to address, however, was the likelihood that we will over-exploit substitute fish species. Rather than simply switching from one to the next as fisheries crash, we need to find …

1 April 2009

Dam solutions

From Peter Fournier

Kate Ravilious reports on the Norwegian company Statkraft's proposal to build a football-stadium-sized plant along a Norwegian fjord that would produce, at best, 25 megawatts of electricity by a process based on osmosis (28 February, p 40) . Such a gigantic plant would be expensive, and the scheme requires a large block of land and …

1 April 2009

Stimulating smells

From Peter Manson

With reference to the article "Fart molecule could be next Viagra" (7 March, p 14) , does hydrogen sulphide only work when you inject it, or could the nightly accumulation of H 2 S from wind trapped under the bedclothes be related to the phenomenon of nocturnal penile tumescence?

1 April 2009

For the record

• Victoria Todd, whose research we reported in the news story "Oil rigs may be fit for porpoise" (21 March, p 8), is at Ocean Science Consulting, not as we stated. • We mangled the name of the L'Anse aux Meadows settlement when we referred to it in our Histories piece about the Vikings (21 …

Issue no. 2702 published 4 April 2009

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop