Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


3 June 2009

Healthy vocabulary

From Nancy Blake

Helen Pilcher highlights the strength of the nocebo effect, in which negative expectations can produce harmful effects (16 May, p 30) . A study of the language used in the Milton model of hypnosis could help doctors who wonder how to inform patients of potential side effects without inadvertently suggesting that they acquire them. If …

3 June 2009

Alternative medicine

From George Lewith, Complementary and Integrated Medicine Research Unit, University of Southampton

David Allen Green suggests that there is an increasing trend towards complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) practitioners threatening libel action against those who criticise them (16 May, p 24) . I am unaware of anybody prior to the chiropractors he describes taking this course of action in the UK. Furthermore, as a medically qualified researcher …

3 June 2009

How to see yourself

From Tapas Basu, Indian Statistical Institute

Out-of-body experience (OBE) is an intriguing and controversial topic on which there are only a handful of publications. In their letter (11 April, p 22) , Eric Altschuler and Vilayanur Ramachandran claim that their 2007 paper ( Perception , vol 36, p 632 ) was the "first to report a method to perceive being outside …

3 June 2009

Power to the people

From Larry Curley

If a severe climatic or violent event were to take out several large generators, for example the Severn barrage in the UK (18 April, p 32) , a considerable number of buildings would cease to function. If every building generated its own electricity, it is likely many of them would still be running after such …

3 June 2009

Antimatter universe

From Perry Bebbington

Could it be that there is an anti-universe and that it existed, or exists, before our universe? It might explain where all the antimatter is (25 April, p 36) . Perhaps the big bang created two universes: ours which goes forward in time, and an anti-universe going backwards in time. Of course, from the perspective …

3 June 2009

Pitch-perfect position

From Stephen Taylor

Hazel Muir reports that those who speak tonal languages are more likely to have perfect pitch (2 May, p 10) . I do not have perfect pitch myself, but as a doctor and an organist I have long been fascinated by its mechanism. It is difficult to imagine the brain having a standard pitch reference, …

3 June 2009

Yogi boo-boo

From Brad Fregger

I won't try to represent Maharishi Mahesh Yogi's quantum physics, but I take issue with Amanda Gefter's contention that he didn't become famous until the Beatles got involved with him (18 April, p 46) . In fact, he started touring the world in 1958 and didn't meet the Beatles until 1967. The Beatles had little …

3 June 2009

Dopey regulations

From Michael Kellock

The recent flurry of letters about smoking regulations in various countries prompted me to comment on the lunacy that can sometimes result from the application of poorly thought-out rules ( 18 April, p 24 , and 2 May, p 24 ). In Dutch coffee shops, where marijuana can be purchased without risking legal penalty, new …

3 June 2009

Problem participles

From Hector Casal

I found the article "Seeing with sound" by Daniel Kish (11 April, p 31) inspiring. Thank you for including it in New Scientist . I was, however, struck by the sentence "What is it like to 'see' the world using sonar?" beneath the headline. It reminded me of a similar construction that appeared in the …

3 June 2009

Power of love

From Dorothy Shaw

The feature on ways of encouraging creativity (9 May, p 32) was interesting, but there was one glaring omission – love, especially the unrequited kind.

3 June 2009

Our unique bubble

From Jerry Barton

There were excellent illustrations in your article on the multiverse (2 May, p 35) . Does the choice of bubble wrap illustrate the hills and valleys of the multiverse? I wondered why the bubbles were all deflated – and then asked myself, who had all the fun? Is there perhaps one unique inflated bubble somewhere …

Issue no. 2711 published 6 June 2009

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop