Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


24 June 2009

Open letter to all UK chiropractors

From Edzard Ernst, Complementary Medicine Group, Peninsula Medical School

This is an invitation to all UK chiropractors to stop the confusions, misunderstandings and animosities that arose during the recent debate about the effectiveness of chiropractic for non-spinal conditions such as asthma and otitis. I herewith invite all of you to state clearly where you stand. Many of your websites promote chiropractic as a treatment …

24 June 2009

Ancient secrets

From Elizabeth Young

Andrew Robinson tells us the Etruscans were a "prehistoric civilisation that arose in western Italy – in what is now Tuscany and parts of Umbria" (30 May, p 24) . In fact, the great Etruscan civilisation – the Etruscan Federation – arose in today's northern Lazio, including Rome itself, as my husband and I detail …

24 June 2009

Circus cruelty

From Craig Redmond, The Captive Animals' Protection Society

You report on a study of animal circuses by the University of Bristol, UK (23 May, p 5) . The British government is still stalling over a pledge made three years ago to stop wild animals appearing in circuses. This timely study shows why it must follow through on its commitment. It shouldn't really take …

24 June 2009

Flat Earth

From Mark Brandon

In discussing whether the universe is flat, Eugenie Samuel Reich compares this premise to the myth that once upon a time, we believed the Earth was flat (16 May, p 15). However, if the BBC's QI programme is correct, and its entire stall is set out on reporting the truth, there is no evidence whatever …

24 June 2009

The two vectors

From David Gilbert

C. P. Snow correctly identified the self-segregation of our intellectuals into two mutually isolated cultures (2 May, p 26) , but he did not understand the reason behind their mutual contempt, which is their "vector disparity". Any thought process can be classified into one of two modes, either analytical/investigative or creative/constructive. Both cultures include examples …

24 June 2009

Ballast buoyancy

From David Hobday

I think Feedback and Paul Spicker took a poorly aimed shot at the advertisement for "5 star Luxury European River Cruises" when remarking on its assertion that the cabin windows don't sink below water level "even when passing under low bridges" (30 May) . Our vintage paddle steamers on the Murray river often need to …

24 June 2009

Black Sea life

From Pamela Kemp

In his review of Alanna Mitchell's Seasick , Fred Pearce states that the Black Sea "has been lifeless for thousands of years" (9 May, p 45). This is not true: the upper levels of the Black Sea have lots of aquatic life. It is only the lower level which is anoxic.

24 June 2009

For the record

• In our story on premature babies' posture and IQ, we should have said that researchers filmed the babies 11 to 16 weeks after their expected birth date, had they reached full term, rather than after their actual birth date (13 June, p 12) . • The correct link to the work by Mark Bulmer …

Issue no. 2714 published 27 June 2009

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop