Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


29 July 2009

Nuclear decay puzzle

From Rudi Van Nieuwenhove

Working at a nuclear research centre as I do, I found Justin Mullins's article on seasonal variations in radioactive decay most intriguing (27 June, p 42) . I remember a previous New Scientist article (21 October 2006, p 36) reporting that Claus Rolfs and colleagues had shown they could modify the radioactive decay of certain …

29 July 2009

What war is good for

From Ewa Bacon, Lewis University

John Horgan argues that war is not an innate part of human nature, and discusses the possibility that the human race is heading towards a more peaceful way of living (4 July, p 38) . However, he does not consider the function of war in society. It is not enough to look at the cost …

29 July 2009

Uncritical sceptics

From Josh Mitteldorf

Richard Wiseman reported a negative result from his Twitter experiment on remote vision (13 June, p 23) . The experiment involved Wiseman going to a location and asking participants to choose one of five photos that matched their intuition of his surroundings. This leaves much room for uncontrolled variables, such as the choice of the …

29 July 2009

Set inventions free

From Lawrence D'Oliveiro

In your interview with James Dyson he argues that without the protection afforded by patents inventors would not invent (11 July, p 20) . However, the evidence suggests that patents can instead block invention. The Wright brothers, who were made so much of in the Dyson interview, in their attempts to protect their patent rights …

29 July 2009

Converging cultures

From David Lowenthal

In common with other observers, most of your correspondents seem to agree that C. P. Snow's "two cultures" gap is now wider than ever ( 2 May, p 26 , and subsequent letters 30 May, p 20 , 20 June, p 25 and 27 June, p 27 ). Yet there are recent signs of convergence, …

29 July 2009

Ideas come round

From Donald Rooum

Mark Brandon writes that there is no evidence people ever believed the Earth is flat (27 June, p 27) . In fact, Christians believed it for centuries. The book of Genesis states that God created the sky in the form of an inverted bowl holding a mass of water above the flat Earth. Scientists already …

29 July 2009

Nuclear washout

From Stephen Lunn

You report that sea-level rises of up to 5 metres are possible within 300 years (4 July, p 28) . This timescale is well within the half-lives of many of the elements in radioactive waste, yet all the locations for nuclear new-builds that I have seen mooted are in low-lying coastal locations, and all would …

29 July 2009

Stimulated discourse

From Andrew McFarland

When discussing the female prostate, Elaine Morgan draws a comparison between it and human male nipples, which she describes as "functionless" analogues of the female version (4 July, p 24) . This fails to take male sexual function into account. Male nipples do not have the child-rearing function of female nipples, but to brand them …

29 July 2009

Dino anatomy

From Sasha Lauer

I was amused by Feedback's theory, prompted by cinematic depictions of tackle-free dinosaurs, that their extinction resulted from a physical inability to procreate (20 June) . I'm no expert, but modern reptiles generally seem to keep their genitalia and cloacal opening tucked well out of harm's way – think of the complications for snakes if …

29 July 2009

For the record

• In a lead-acid battery, it is the sulphate ions that are transferred between the electrolyte and the electrodes, not the lead as we said (18 July, p 42)

Issue no. 2719 published 1 August 2009

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop