Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


26 August 2009

Allergy dangers

From Janice Duncan

Andrew Watson's article on food allergies was both enlightening and alarming (1 August, p 28) . Our daughter died about three years ago, aged 16, of anaphylaxis following ingestion of nut traces in chocolate. We had known about her allergy since she was a toddler, but the increasing incidence of the warning "may contain nut …

26 August 2009

What miracle?

From Max Davies

Hugh McLachlan argues that natural laws are by definition laws that cannot be transgressed – even by God (8 August, p 26) . He thus displays a defective understanding of what miracles in the Judaeo-Christian world are taken to be. The inhabitants of first-century Palestine understood perfectly well that all births required preceding sexual intercourse, …

26 August 2009

Make war no more

From Bruce Denness

Terence Kealey referred to a comprehensive analysis by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) of factors that might explain different growth rates of some of the world's leading economies (25 July, p 28) . This showed that only privately funded research and development led to economic growth, while publicly funded R&D did not. …

26 August 2009

Hyperoptimism

From Nicholas Thomas

Is the pursuit of hypersonic flight the aviation industry's equivalent of controlled nuclear fusion (25 July, p 30) ? Even if sustained hypersonic flight powered by anything other than immensely wasteful rockets proves possible, it is unlikely ever to be practical. The Lockheed SR-71 "Blackbird" is the only Mach 3 plane ever built, for good …

26 August 2009

Altruism's reward

From Michael O'Hara

Kate Douglas suggests that if people get a buzz from altruistic acts, they are not purely altruistic (8 August, p 28) . I can certainly attest to this. When cycling along a local street, I am occasionally accosted by people asking for small amounts of money. While I do not know if they are being …

26 August 2009

Odds off

From Roger Mitchell

If you place an even-money bet at roulette (red or black) will you inevitably win a small amount if you double your bet after every loss (8 August, p 35) ? No, for two reasons. First, casinos set betting limits on each table so if, for example, you have been doubling your bet after consecutive …

26 August 2009

Two cultures

From Jesper Valgreen

David Gilbert proposes that a disparity in the "vector relationship" between analysis and creativity explains the segregation of and alienation between the humanities and science (27 June, p 27) . It seems to me that the problem of "two cultures" (2 May, p 26) rather arises from the positivism of the French philosopher Auguste Comte, …

26 August 2009

Aye aye, Captain Kirk

From Alan Sherwood

I cannot agree with Bryn Glover's rosy view of Star Trek as a socialist utopia (18 July, p 27) . The original series was about a warship and its crew, all dutifully obeying orders and Starfleet regulations. True, many stories did not involve military action, just as armed forces today also do humanitarian operations. We …

26 August 2009

For the record

• The DOI for Steven Clapcote's paper on epileptic mice (8 August, p 14) is 10.1073/pnas.0904817106 . • The Planck length – the quantum of distance – is 1.6 × 10 -35 metres, not "about 10 -33 metres" (15 August, p 26) .

Issue no. 2723 published 29 August 2009

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop