Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


23 September 2009

Late light licked?

From Ian Guy

In "The light that came late" (15 August, p 26) Anil Ananthaswamy cites esoteric theories based on string theory and quantum gravity to explain why high-energy photons from extremely distant gamma-ray bursts appear to arrive later than lower-energy photons produced in the same event. I would suggest a simpler explanation for this phenomenon: optical dispersion. …

23 September 2009

War and weaponry

From Alastair Breingan

I agree with Cedric Griffiths (22 August, p 24) , Frank Jackson and Peggy Conroy (25 July, p 26) that war is significantly driven by the profit motive. But unlike Griffiths, I can only imagine captains of industry uttering hypocritical oaths, rather than the Hippocratic ones he suggests. Indeed, a "do no harm" law would …

23 September 2009

Restored waves

From Frank Fahy

Andy Howse suggests that sea waves lose energy because they have to lift the water against the force of gravity (8 August, p 25) . All mechanical waves involve an interaction between the inertia of the supporting medium and the restoring force particular to that wave; in this case, by the rise of the water …

23 September 2009

Can't run from DNA

From Dov Greenbaum and Mark Gerstein

We read Katrina Voss's article on open access to genomic information (22 August, p 22) with great interest. Summing up her argument, she quotes her father: "I'm not worried, I'm just not that important." Narcissists aside, we can all agree that we aren't that important to the rest of the world. However, what Voss fails …

23 September 2009

Allergic, not nuts

From Tom York

Rosemary Bentley suggests that a substantial degree of confusion exists over whether a peanut allergy also extends to nuts (29 August, p 26) . Although I do not suffer from peanut allergy myself, I work with a large number of people who do. While it is correct to say that some are unsure whether they …

23 September 2009

Common ideal

From Bryn Glover

I agree with Mark van Vugt's well-reasoned, sensible and logical proposals for overcoming the environmental tragedy of the commons by everyone working together (22 August, p 40) , but I doubt that this will spontaneously happen within the few short years we have left before we become overwhelmed with tipping points. I can only assume …

23 September 2009

Warming wobble

From Peter Slessenger

On re-reading Anil Ananthaswamy's article on melting Arctic ice caps (4 July, p 28) , I realise I haven't seen any mention of the Earth's rotation in connection with global warming. If a mass of meltwater sufficient to raise global sea levels by several metres spreads out from within 1600 kilometres of the Earth's axis …

23 September 2009

Ain't got the guts

From Edward Williams

Rick Jefferys writes that "individuals can have significantly different gut flora and other digestive capacities" (15 August, p 22) . A doctor told me of a patient aged about 50 who ate enormously and yet remained exceedingly thin. When he had his appendix removed, the surgeon had a routine look around inside the abdomen, and …

23 September 2009

Mystical roots

From Bob Muirhead

I must agree with Perry Bebbington in supporting your coverage of cold fusion (5 September, p 27) . Much of chemical practice arose from the alchemical search for a "universal solvent" and the philosopher's stone. Astronomy has its roots in astrology – one could go on. The true opponents of progress are conservatives who fight …

23 September 2009

Nose-picking licked

From Alan Hickman

What makes Sophia Dunn think that hoofed animals do not pick their noses (5 September, p 26) ? Cows do it all the time – with their tongues.

23 September 2009

For the record

• The research into the effects of railway privatisation in the UK was published in volume 60 of Social Psychology Quarterly , p 355, not volume 63 (22 August, p 40) . • The feature on other dimensions included a quote from Roger Penrose (29 August, p 34) . The words are indeed Penrose's but …

Issue no. 2727 published 26 September 2009

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop