Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


21 October 2009

Persistent populace?

From George Wiman

An optimistic Jesse Ausubel tells us we are so clever that we will always figure out a way to beat Malthusian predictions of population catastrophe (26 September, p 38) . It has indeed worked so far, as exponential population growth smacks up against merely linear resource growth. In the end, though, he's counting on us …

21 October 2009

What's the buzz?

From Bill Summers

Caroline Williams casts doubt on the received wisdom that the bees' waggle dance is about communicating the direction and distance of a source of food (19 September, p 40) . Having kept bees for 37 years, I concur. Waggle dances can be seen most frequently in early spring. If their purpose is to provide directions, …

21 October 2009

No second chance

From Charles Goodwin

I agree with Harriet Coleman (22 August, p 24) that the debate about global warming is really about preserving our way of life, and that "in the worst case we will be trying to save enough civilisation not to have to start again from the Stone Age". However, I would also add that the chances …

21 October 2009

Mortality rate

From Rosie Caswell

In his article on genetic engineering, Michael Le Page claims that genetically modified Golden Rice will "help to improve health and reduce child mortality, which will ultimately contribute to a reduction in population growth" (12 September, p 37) . I disagree. Surely the population will increase if people live longer because they are healthier, and …

21 October 2009

Relative earnings

From Neil Buchan

The chart on "extreme poverty" at the end of part one of your "Blueprint for a better world" series errs in using the classification of earnings below $1.25 per day (12 September, p 30) . This amount, off the tourist trails, in northern India or Chad, for example, would probably buy a whole family a …

21 October 2009

Improving Earth

From Karl Jaeger

I found your "Blueprint for a better world" series interesting ( 12 , 19 and 26 September , and 3 October ), as I am involved in an endeavour called Our Future Planet , which has similar aims. To reduce population by 50 per cent while also offering children and parents a better interactive future, …

21 October 2009

Geo war

From Alyson Bailes

Another plea in your pages for geoengineering (12 September, p 34) makes me wonder if I am alone in my concern about the potential for warlike abuse of these techniques. Several of those now discussed could be used to intentionally damage territories and populations by inciting droughts or floods, or by changing sea or air …

21 October 2009

You dirty rat

From Mark Allan Barnes

In Henry Nicholls's article on taming wild animals, I was intrigued to read that "You can do anything with the tame rats... you can move their arms and legs" (3 October, p 40) . Did those rats that were bred to be aggressive also have arms? Was there interest from the military in the idea …

21 October 2009

Elementology

From Philip Stewart

Copernicus was a great scientist and should be commemorated, though Aristarchus of Samos came up with the heliocentric theory 17 centuries earlier. But it seems perverse to name element 112 after Copernicus when there are contributors to the periodic system who have not yet been honoured (25 July, p 7) .

21 October 2009

For the record

• We misspelled John Cockcroft's name in our editorial on ITER, sorry (10 October, p 5) . • Apologies also to Georgios Yannakakis whose name we misspelled in our article on adaptive computer games (10 October, p 21) .

Issue no. 2731 published 24 October 2009

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop