Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


28 October 2009

Drive me tame

From Geoffrey Patton

In his article on taming wild animals, Henry Nicholls presents geneticist Dmitry Belyaev's intriguing proposition that when our ancient ancestors approached a herd of animals, they identified the less skittish ones and took them home to breed (3 October, p 40) . Although the article presents the trait being selected for as tameness rather than …

28 October 2009

Future-proof farms

From Ann Hansen

Your article on engineering pain-free farm animals (5 September, p 8) and the accompanying editorial "Pain-free but not guilt-free" (5 September, p 5) , would have benefited from the input of people with experience in rearing domestic livestock. Livestock producers already expend a lot of thought and investment endeavouring to keep livestock comfortable and pain-free, …

28 October 2009

Design from data

From David John Sherwin

W. Brian Arthur and Robert Cailliau both made the argument on your pages that technology progresses through evolutionary mechanisms ( 22 August, p 26 and 19 September, p 27 , respectively). However, it is part of the received wisdom in the field of reliability engineering that no new design is wholly revolutionary or wholly evolutionary. …

28 October 2009

Hypnotic illusion

From Alex Tsander

Nicola Jones reports her experience of hypnosis, during which unsuccessful attempts to make her experience paralysis and blindness are carried out (10 October, p 37) . What she fails to mention is that similar attempts to replicate pathological behaviour with hypnosis date back 70 years at least, most notably to the work of psychiatrist Milton …

28 October 2009

Put a lid on it

From Adam Dawson

To get maximum efficiency on a hot day, (12 September, p 26) Stephen Hodges tell us that he uses a sprinkler to cool the solar cells that he has on the roof of his Jamaican home. There are other forms of cooling that work just as well. For example, over 24 hours a "living roof" …

28 October 2009

Stealthy power

From Patrick Mullen

Since reading about the decimation of bat populations around wind farms (12 May 2007, p 4) , I've wanted to contribute the results of some deviant research I conducted as a boy in the UK. My brother and I used to throw sticks at the bats fluttering outside our bedroom window, for obvious reasons. The …

28 October 2009

For the record

• In our article "Don't provoke the planet" (26 September, p 8) we stated: "A CCS facility at the Sleipner gas field in the North Sea, may have triggered a magnitude 4 earthquake in 2008." This was incorrect: the earthquake was of magnitude 3.1 and was some 55 kilometres away from the Sleipner field. There …

Issue no. 2732 published 31 October 2009

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop