Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


19 May 2010

When votes count

From Sandy Johnson

Ian Stewart's article on the mathematics of voting seems to take pleasure in the fact that no voting system is perfect, while failing to acknowledge that the relative merits of voting systems should be investigated and qualitatively assessed (1 May, p 28) . To my mind, the voting system here in Australia has several advantages, …

19 May 2010

On biodiversity

From Gareth Griffith, Institute of Biological, Environmental and Rural Sciences

It is a major oversight that your article on biodiversity mentions micro-organisms only fleetingly (24 April, p 32) . Furthermore, you report that "our best estimates so far give the number of species between 1.4 and 1.9 million". These numbers ignore David Hawksworth's widely accepted estimate of 1.5 million species of fungi , with the …

19 May 2010

Heavy lifting

From Angus Cairnie

In her article on how much a human can lift, Jessica Marshall begins by mentioning Andy Bolton's record for the heaviest dead lift (17 April, p 34) . Bolton holds this record in power lifting, but the heaviest dead lift record belongs to Benedikt Magnússon of Iceland, who lifted 498.9 kilograms using straps. Marshall also …

19 May 2010

Pond life

From Sam Hughes

I found the explanation for Minnesotan frog deformities put forward in Jessica Griggs's article somewhat implausible (13 March, p 48) . Griggs correctly states that there are perfectly natural reasons why some of the frogs may have had limb irregularities, and suggests parasites and dragonfly larvae as causes for the extra and missing legs respectively. …

19 May 2010

Carcasses for crops

From John Stanton

Sam Little recounts how donkey carcasses used to be planted beneath asparagus fields to improve yields (1 May, p 25) . It was traditional when constructing a vinery in Victorian times to bury a large animal, even a carthorse if available, in the bed where the vines were to be planted. In later times when …

19 May 2010

Traffic hack

From Alan Chattaway

Nic Fleming envisages a future of self-driving cars that communicate with each other about road conditions (3 April, p 34) . If this vision becomes reality, each car will in effect form part of a self-optimising system. Unfortunately, when such systems contain no slack, they can fail spectacularly if a single component goes wrong; traffic …

19 May 2010

For the record

• Jeffrey Macklis, whose studies of brain-cell generation we mentioned (3 April, p 29) , is at Harvard University, not MIT. Contrary to what we stated, many groups apart from his own have found so-called "progenitor" cells, possibly left over from brain development, in parts of the brain in which new neurons are not normally …

Issue no. 2761 published 22 May 2010

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop