Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


10 November 2010

Probably likely

From John Burns

As a scientist and engineer, I was amazed to find that the patterns described in Rachel Courtland's article on Benford's law came as such a surprise (16 October, p 10) . It is only natural that numbers that are randomly distributed on a logarithmic scale translate into this observed pattern. Compare the spacing between 1 …

10 November 2010

Robots on the road

From Steve Fankuchen

Google's CEO Eric Schmidt says that the desirability of cars that drive themselves is a no-brainer (16 October, p 19). I disagree. These cars, which Google has unconscionably put on the roads of California, cannot plan adequately for the unplanned. They can be programmed for varying traffic laws, but not for the multitude of different …

10 November 2010

Nobel controversy

From Ian Davies

I was surprised and disappointed by your coverage of the award of a Nobel prize for IVF pioneer Robert Edwards (9 October, p 7) . I felt that you gave too much prominence to the criticism, especially that of the Catholic church. I understand that it was and is a controversial issue, but to put …

10 November 2010

Better nature

From Larry Stoter

You quote Michele Aresta, Director of Italy's National Consortium on Catalysis, who suggests that humankind "can fly much better than birds", and can therefore supersede photosynthesis easily (25 September, p 48) . Comparing our attempts at flight with that of birds tells us that attempting to out-do nature at photosynthesis is going to be considerably …

10 November 2010

Double vision

From Tom Radford

Reading Jessica Griggs's recent news story on visual illusions (4 September, p 14) , I was reminded of a picture I painted as a student, some 50 years ago. It started out as a picture of a man sleeping under one of those enormous hats in a typical "cartoon Mexican" pose: sitting on the ground …

10 November 2010

Silent soundtrack

From Jud Ghilotti

My wife lacks the inner voice that most people have, just as David Dunthorn's wife does (16 October, p 27) . She does not experience any kind of inner dialogue, and when she reads she hears nothing. She says that she knows what the words mean as soon as she sees them. She doesn't have …

10 November 2010

Learning to see

From Anne Murray

I was surprised that David Robson should think it necessary to go back in time to test whether knowing a berry's name might help someone find it more quickly (4 September, p 30) . Modern bird watchers, botanists and other nature aficionados are all familiar with the way that one's ability to identify species increases …

10 November 2010

Sweat and wine

From Giorgio Garuzzo

It's not only the Zulus in South Africa who treat fever by increasing body temperature (11 September, p 30) . In the Piedmont region of Italy, the traditional treatment is to cover the patient in blankets and make them drink a full bottle of strong red wine – barolo for those who can afford it, …

10 November 2010

Esoteric physics

From Tim Sprod

Is any other reader inexorably reminded of the medieval scholastics trying to calculate how many angels can dance on the head of a pin, when they read articles in New Scientist about cosmology and particle physics? Rachel Courtland's "Countdown to oblivion" – addressing a supposed paradox arising from a mathematical model of the multiverse – …

10 November 2010

For the record

• In our article on endangered species (30 October, p 7) we mention the leopard magpie moth ( Zerenopsis lepida , or Z. leopardina , depending on which lepidopterist we talked to). But any lepidopterist will tell you that it is not this species that we pictured, but a Millar's tiger moth ( Callioratis millari …

Issue no. 2786 published 13 November 2010

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop