Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


24 November 2010

For whom the bell tills

From Alan Chattaway

While your article on regulation of the oestrogen mimic bisphenol A (23 October, p 26) was in press, Canada declared BPA "toxic". Under North American Free Trade Agreement rules, affected parties in the US can challenge this ruling on the grounds that it restricts trade within NAFTA. It will be interesting to see how this …

24 November 2010

Mutual aid

From Larry Fast

Thank you for the all-too-brief article on super-evolution among the "50 Ideas" ( 9 October, p 32 ). It is clear enough to me that surviving millions of years is about resilient ecosystems, not selfish individuals. Even bacterial mats seem more aware of their community responsibilities than selfish capitalists. Looking at the heterogeneous colonies walking …

24 November 2010

Seconds out

From Chris Oldman

Brian Bowsher, celebrating SI units' anniversary, states that all bar one "have been defined by universal, natural constants" (30 October, p 29) . But one SI base unit, the metre, is defined in terms of light travel based on another SI unit, the second. While the speed of light might be a universal, natural constant, …

24 November 2010

Lamarck's legacy

From Steve Wilson

I was fascinated to learn that trauma experienced by mice can affect their offspring through epigenetic transfer (6 November, p 8) , but searched the article in vain for one name: Jean-Baptiste Lamarck. Since he died before Darwin published On the Origin of Species , he did not get the chance to adjust his theories …

24 November 2010

Our bipedal origins

From Elaine Morgan

For 50 years we were assured that our ancestors became bipedal and naked as a result of living on the savannah. More recently it has been established that they became bipedal before they ever lived on the savannah. Why then did we ever acquire this unique form of locomotion? Your eight-page guide to human origins …

24 November 2010

Grid puzzle

From Dave Prichard

You seem to exaggerate the problem of solar power overloading the electricity grid (30 October, p 4) . I understand that buildings with solar panels draw power from the grid when they need it but may supply it to the grid if they generate more than they need. I can't believe it is beyond the …

24 November 2010

Heli go again

From Daniel Robinson

The problems outlined in your article on hybrid helicopters (16 October, p 20) have been solved several times during the history of flight. One notable British example was the Fairey Rotodyne, designed in the 1950s by the same company that produced the Swordfish torpedo bomber, used by the Royal Navy in the second world war. …

24 November 2010

Moral brains

From Mary Midgley

Some writers in your section "Science wakes up to morality" ( 16 October, p 41 ) clearly feel they are engaged in territorial wars against philosophy and religion. Several contributors, notably Patricia Churchland, plainly think that neurobiological explanation supersedes all other kinds of inquiry. But would a detailed account of the brain states used in …

24 November 2010

Nature and nurture

From Derek Bolton

Evelyn Fox Keller's apparent dismissal of the use of statistical analysis to resolve the nature/nurture debate is too sweeping (18 September, p 28) . Imagine you could take a random sample of embryos and environments from a given community and try out all combinations of genes and environment. Standard regression tests would reveal which has …

24 November 2010

Fluffy tales

From Kay Bagon

Your article about the healing power of pets (6 November, p 30) reminded me of a visit I made to a Reform synagogue in Boston one Friday evening this summer. I was most surprised to see that one of the congregants, sitting quietly in the front row next to some children, was a small white …

24 November 2010

For the record

• The cyber-security test range in Fareham, Hampshire, UK, is not a Ministry of Defence facility as we mistakenly implied. It was built, is owned and was opened by Northrop Grumman, with defence minister Gerald Howarth MP as its guest of honour (23 October, p 21) .

Issue no. 2788 published 27 November 2010

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop