Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


1 December 2010

Urban myth

From Chris Smaje

The notion that the city is greener than the countryside is rapidly becoming a modern myth. But Shanta Barley misses the fact that what happens in cities and the countryside are inextricably linked (6 November, p 32) . If you assume that deforestation and industrial agriculture are afflictions of rural life that have nothing to …

1 December 2010

Carbon farming

From Lynn Erselius

One thing missing from your list of 50 ideas that will change science ( 16 October, p 32 ) is the idea of farmland as a dynamic carbon sink. Permanent pastures store large amounts of carbon, and organic matter can accumulate in systems such as permaculture in which ploughing is avoided. We also know that …

1 December 2010

Network overload

From Tom Phillips, GSM Association

At the GSM Association, which represents the interests of the mobile communications industry worldwide, we have a slightly different take on the problem of smartphones overloading networks from that in your article (30 October, p 44) . We agree there is a wireless capacity issue, but think developments in mobile technology will help. For example, …

1 December 2010

Weird ways

From Elizabeth Young

The question "Who's the oddball?" is not only fascinating but also politically significant (13 November, p 42) . The WEIRD – western, educated, industrialised, rich and democratic – people the article describes are behind a lot of western, particularly American, policy towards China: and a dangerous policy it is, too. WEIRD people, Laura Spinney tells …

1 December 2010

Eating Skippy

From Michael Kellock

Wendy Zukerman states that "kangaroo meat was not available in Australia for human consumption until 1980 – 20 years later than most countries it was exported to". Not so. When I was at the University of Melbourne in the late 1950s, kangaroo casserole was available every Thursday in the student union eatery. It was a …

1 December 2010

Inductive research

From Peter Gladwell

Ian Roberts rightly highlights the misinterpretation of medical case studies that has encouraged some clinicians to use treatments which have not been evaluated (25 September, p 28) . Unlike randomised trials, case studies were never intended to test a hypothesis and therefore cannot indicate that a particular treatment is effective. They belong to a completely …

1 December 2010

Time travel test

From Andy Biddulph

This letter is a test of quantum time travel (20 November, p 34) . I, in your past, am sending you, in my future, a message. When you print this, in my future, you will, by post-selection, be sending me, in your past, a message telling me what to type when I have finished my …

Issue no. 2789 published 4 December 2010

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop