Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


23 March 2011

Beauty, truth

From Les Higgins

The more I read of Giovanni Vignale's "The power of the abstract", the more I smiled and the more at ease I felt with the world (26 February, p 32) . He presented the truest spirit of the scientist – the student, the creator, the master, the supplicant, the truth-sayer, the poet, the fool. All …

23 March 2011

Bohm's a way

From Eric Van

It seems grossly premature to declare a victory for Niels Bohr in his great debate with Einstein over the meaning of quantum mechanics (26 February, p 36) . Yes, the violation of Bell's inequality in experiments by Alain Aspect and others appears increasingly likely to rule out "local realism", Einstein's favoured interpretation. But many physicists …

23 March 2011

The real risk

From Guy Cox

The otherwise excellent exposé by Marianne Freiberger and Rachel Thomas of the misuse of medical statistics itself fell into a common trap by quoting statistics as annual rates ( 12 February, p 40 ). This often makes numbers look reassuringly low, but is easily misinterpreted. For example, adenocarcinoma of the oesophagus affecting 0.00569 per cent …

23 March 2011

With feeling

From Curt White

In responding to David Robson's important but imprecise statement that "up to 80 per cent of our mental experiences are verbal" (4 September 2010, p 30) , Ben Haller was partly justified in saying that "raw visual percepts – such as colour – outnumber other kinds of mental experience by orders of magnitude" (30 October …

23 March 2011

Beware game bubble

From Harry Dewulf

I am a keen gamer, with or without a computer, and this is not unrelated to my two chosen professions of IT specialist and writer/editor. The "gamification" of our everyday lives that MacGregor Campbell describes (8 January, p 36) certainly pushes buttons and will probably catch on in the way Campbell anticipates. I would, however, …

23 March 2011

Stick in the mud

From Carl Zetie

Your correspondents Steve Champion and Carol Primrose offer differing explanations for the origin of the term "wrong end of the stick" (12 February, p 27) . I believe that both are correct, and that the modern term is a linguistic superposition of two distinct expressions. Growing up, I was familiar with the term "the shitty …

23 March 2011

I am what I am

From Martin Hunt

I am frustrated. What by? By having to describe myself as the opposite of something that I am not, rather than what I actually am. Atheists of the UK unite: in the census due here on 27 March , describe yourself not as "atheist" but as "scientific realist", to demonstrate what you do believe in, …

23 March 2011

Glad rags

From J. C. Ellison

Helen Thomson's article on Darwinian dating was great, but it missed a woman's core courtship tool: high oestrogen levels (12 February, p 36) . When she is fertile a woman has more symmetry in her ear lobes, nostrils and breasts; she dresses in a more alluring manner and her body language is encouraging of courtship. …

23 March 2011

Futurama was first

From Beth Haigh

I was surprised, and a little disappointed, to see no reference to the Futurama episode "A Big Piece of Garbage" (series 1, episode 8) in the article about the Nasal Ranger (12 February, p 21) . I would have thought that at least one person on the team behind New Scientist would be a big …

23 March 2011

For the record

• In a letter to New Scientist , Barbara Sommerville wrote that the more acceptable longer-term approach to population control is to "educate women and supply them with contraceptives", but her reference to the specific efficacy of education for women disappeared in editing (5 March, p 32) . Sorry. • Science is never still in …

Issue no. 2805 published 26 March 2011

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop