Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


20 April 2011

Endless energy

From George Crisp

Mark Buchanan's article on the limits of wind power raised some interesting aspects of renewable energy (2 April, p 8) , but there were some intriguing omissions. First, is Buchanan unaware that wind speeds, and therefore wave energy, increase with global warming. This has already been documented and should be factored into the free-energy balance. …

20 April 2011

Bonus bonanza

From Martin van Raay

Cheating bankers always prosper, says Mark Buchanan (19 March, p 30) . One reason for this is that they control their own bonuses – a privilege most employees don't have. A solution might be to give every employee the right to decide their own salary and bonus. Inevitably, everyone would want to award themselves top …

20 April 2011

Nuclear question

From Richard Arthur

Fail-safe technology is an essential goal in all nuclear power generation, and yet it continues to be ignored by an arrogant industry ( 26 March, p 8 ). The question that should be asked is why zirconium is still used in cladding for nuclear fuel rods after being implicated in the Three Mile Island disaster. …

20 April 2011

The Santa delusion

From John McCallum

Jonathan Lanman refers to the supposed "universality of religious beliefs", as many have done before (26 March, p 38) . In the society I grew up in, one might also have referred to a universality of belief in Santa Claus, but only if the subjects in the study were restricted to children under 8. As …

20 April 2011

God and evolution

From Nigel Depledge

I was intrigued by Michael Marshall's interview with Martin Nowak (19 March, p 34) , but one statement puzzled me deeply. Nowak states that "a purely scientific interpretation of evolution does not generate an argument in favour of atheism... Evolution is not an argument against God, any more than gravity is." I have yet to …

20 April 2011

Belief abridged

From Alan Charlton

Being an atheist and easily led, I tried to enter "Scientific Realist" in the religion box in the recent UK census, as suggested by Martin Hunt (26 March, p 36) . Only 17 characters were allowed. I had to make do with "ScientificRealist". Seventeen characters does seem a bit miserly to describe what I "do …

20 April 2011

Genteel steal

From Fiona Taylor

When listing the means of escape of plant species (19 March, p 18) , Andy Coghlan apparently overlooked one of the most obvious: the steady flow of keen gardeners pinching a bit off, with the delicious challenge of trying to root it at home. I know that I am not alone in having memories of …

20 April 2011

Mars conspiracy

From Gus Ferguson

David Shiga told of the Russian mock-up of a mission to Mars, which is intended to help with planning a real mission (5 February, p 10) . Is it too late to try to convince conspiracy theorists that this is in fact an elaborate front for an actual mission to Mars? If the belief takes …

20 April 2011

The wrong register

From Chris Finn

Alan Chattaway's call to name the phenomenon where something is known more widely by an erroneous name than by its correct one (29 January, p 25) immediately brought to mind another common misuse. Many people in the UK refer to their local office for the registration of births, marriages and deaths as the "registry office". …

20 April 2011

For the record

The photograph in the box in "The secret life of plants" (26 March, p 48) was wrongly accredited. It was taken by Justin Runyon (courtesy of the De Moraes and Mescher labs).

Issue no. 2809 published 23 April 2011

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop