Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


22 February 2012

Solar uncertainty

From Jay Pasachoff, Field Memorial Professor of Astronomy, Williams College

Your editorial on solar storms says, "there will be another maximum in the early 2020s, another about 11 years later, and so on until... well, who knows" (4 February, p 3) . However, research from three independent teams of solar astronomers, reported at last June's meeting of the Solar Physics Division of the American Astronomical …

22 February 2012

Tweeted and deleted

From José Beltrán Escavy

Your interview with Paul Mason was headlined "The revolution will be tweeted" ( 4 February, p 28 ). Actually, it won't. Not after Twitter itself said that it will implement regional censorship because certain countries "have different ideas about the contours of freedom of expression ". This policy means that future revolutions will not have …

22 February 2012

White planet

From Mike Wilson

The diagram accompanying your feature on the potential impact of green energy on climate says that Earth is radiating 380 terawatts (TW) less heat now than before the industrial revolution (28 January, p 34) . Could increasing the albedo of Earth so that it reflects, globally, 380 TW more be enough to counterbalance the warming? …

22 February 2012

A sack of potatoes

From John Davies

The explanation for the phrase "order may vary" appearing on a packet of potatoes of mixed colours is prosaic, despite Feedback's best efforts (4 February) . Even more yawn-inducing is the fact that the words are as stipulated by European Council Directive 2000/13/EC . The list of ingredients on a food packet must be in …

22 February 2012

Path to change

From Constance Lever-Tracy, Flinders University

Fred Pearce's look at the efficacy of wildlife corridors is mainly about the lack of evidence of genetic mixing between groups from different ends of such corridors (4 February, p 26) . The widening of the gene pool would not be their only advantage. Adaptation to climate change necessitates and induces movement, as climate zones …

22 February 2012

Folkloric science

From Steve Wilson

In his round-up of lost scientific treasures, Michael Marshall states that the possible existence of long-necked seals "is now relegated to cryptozoology, the search for semi-mythical species" (4 February, p 40) . We are in danger of starving promising avenues of research of attention and funding because cryptozoology is not considered "real" science. This is …

22 February 2012

Ancient symbol

From Allen Reynolds

In his letter, Doug Legge proposes the light bulb as a universal symbol for science (21 January, p 29) . The incandescent bulb is so last century, and his screw fitting would be out of place around here – our bulbs usually have bayonet connectors. Could it be that we cannot have a universal symbol, …

22 February 2012

Heads up

From Ben Haller

In your editorial on advances in detecting speech from brain activity, you make the claim that "there is absolutely no prospect of anyone looking inside your skull without your consent" (4 February, p 3) . Really? What is to stop a government from immobilising a person and performing whatever invasive brain scans they wish, up …

22 February 2012

What is life?

From Mathieu Bergounioux

In your article exploring the progression of evolution (21 January, p 35) , I found the idea of measuring complexity in terms of energy rate density (the amount of energy flowing through each gram of a system per second) new and fascinating. I wonder if a threshold expressed in that unit could define "what is …

22 February 2012

Taste of justice

From David Yelland

I was intrigued by the findings of Jonathan Levav and colleagues, which showed judicial decisions becoming more favourable for those in the dock after the judge had had lunch (28 January, p 30) . I will be making a study of fellow inmates' results in court over the following month.

22 February 2012

Big and bigger

From Brian Bonney

Your story "Supermassive barely covers it" (10 December 2011, p 17) , set me wondering how big a black hole can get. The masses quoted must be big enough to engulf entire galaxies, small ones at least. Could even larger black holes exist, perhaps beyond the boundary of the observable universe and capable of engulfing …

22 February 2012

For the record

• The word "equations" was misspelled on the cover of some copies of our 11 February issue. Apologies to readers in the US who picked one up. On the plus side, you now own a collector's item. • In the story on the threat posed by hurricanes to wind turbines (18 February, p 18) the …

Issue no. 2853 published 25 February 2012

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop