Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


20 June 2012

Fun lovin' crows

From Rod Buck

To any persistent observer, the intelligence and personality of crows are undeniable – as outlined in Adrian Barnett's review of Gifts of the Crow (2 June, p 49) . While it could be argued that such interpretations are subjective, the growing number of observations of crow behaviour surely carries some scientific weight. As a hang-glider …

20 June 2012

Lost in translation?

From Rupert Fray, University of Nottingham

The presence of a modified component in messenger RNA (mRNA) – nucleotide base N6-methyladenosine – is an exciting and under-studied area (26 May, p 16) . Your article on the work of Samie Jaffrey's group at Cornell University in New York ( Cell , DOI:10.1016/j.cell.2012.05.003 ) gave the impression that this is a new discovery. …

20 June 2012

Deep danger

From John Hayman

There may be another explanation for how ichthyosaurs – "dino dolphins" – suffered the bends other than rapid surfacing in the presence of predators (26 May, p 17) . They would dive with one atmosphere of pressure in their lungs and when they surfaced, no matter how fast, they would have only one atmosphere of …

20 June 2012

To love and cherish

From Ken Green

Lasting love and the benefits of rearing progeny through a joint effort have developed over centuries of trial and error, and cannot be boiled down to the simple interactions of a few hormones, as proposed in "Engineering love" (12 May, p 28) . Some 70 years ago, my father lamented that it was too easy …

20 June 2012

Irrational outcomes

From Roger Taylor

In your editorial on a possible Greek exit from the eurozone, you wrote: "If the theorists are right, the eurozone was built on quicksand from the start" (26 May, p 3) . The "if" is superfluous and no "theorists" are needed. More interesting, from a scientific point of view, is why no serious scientific study …

20 June 2012

Origins of flight

From Alan Sherwood, Aeronautical engineer

Further to Ian Flett's letter on flying fish (19 May, p 32) , in essence, they are very sophisticated flying machines, lacking only an airborne propulsion system. It is generally considered that tree-dwellers capable of true flight went through a stage of gliding, like flying squirrels. Flying fish are already more capable than any arboreal …

20 June 2012

Time flows by

From Ian H. Machell

The idea that the Yupno tribe of Papua New Guinea regard time as flowing uphill could be unwarranted (2 June, p 14) . When gesturing downriver, they're probably just indicating water (or events) that have passed them (or happened) some time ago: the "past". When pointing upriver, they're probably just indicating water (or events) still …

20 June 2012

Turing's ACE

From Mark Dowson

Your Instant Expert ( 2 June ) on the legacy of Alan Turing did not mention the Pilot ACE (Automatic Computing Engine) which has a strong claim to be regarded as the first high-speed, stored-program, Von Neumann-architecture digital computer. It was based on Turing's original design for a full ACE version and was built at …

20 June 2012

Matter of debate

From Ted Rockley

The idea of a group coming to a correct or better answer than an individual as a result of our innate argumentative nature has its merits (26 May, p 32) . However, "groupthink" in the real world is often responsible for bizarre outcomes, in particular in politics. Coupled with the suggestion that individual choice is …

20 June 2012

Birth of democracy

From Jack Hampson

You reported Richard Cincotta's research, which shows that autocratic nations with a low median age are unlikely to secure democracy in the wake of revolution, such as the Arab spring (19 May, p 8) . Although birth rates had full coverage, a key contributor to understanding the data for ageing populations must also include survival …

20 June 2012

Quantum socks

From Steve Field

You posed the question of how big an object can be and still show quantum properties (14 April, p 8) . In my experience, it can be at least as big as a sock, as they seem to pop out of existence at random (check the number of odd ones in the sock drawer). I …

20 June 2012

For the record

• We got our moons in a muddle. In our story on possible liquid oceans on Neptune's satellite Triton we used a picture of Saturn's moon Titan (2 June, p 17) .

Issue no. 2870 published 23 June 2012

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop