Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


31 October 2012

The real deal

From Ronnie Hawkins

As a philosopher with a background in biological science, I applaud your recent special issue on reality ( 29 September, p 34 ) as a valuable marker of where we are, and aren't, on this important topic. The take-home message is that those parts of "reality" that are simply our human constructions – "objects" such …

31 October 2012

After a fashion

From Stuart Henderson

I suggest an alternative to "truth decay" in explaining the half-life of citations (22 September, p 36) . New lines of research that give hope of a breakthrough attract many researchers, who then publish on them. Over time, progress generally slows and the breakthrough fails to happen, so researchers switch in droves to the next …

31 October 2012

Times are changing

From Bryn Glover

In her letter, Susan Hall identifies many behavioural patterns that would have been socially acceptable in the past, but which we now find unacceptable, such as racism (13 October, p 31) . It is worth pointing out that various behavioural memes connected with rationality, fairness, altruism, propriety and egalitarianism have been growing and spreading in …

31 October 2012

Reality made simple

From Ian Duerdoth

Amanda Gefter endorsed physicist Eugene Wigner's sentiments on "The unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in the natural sciences" (29 September, p 38) . Perhaps there is a simple and straightforward explanation for the prescience of mathematics. Think of mathematics as essentially the study and classification of all possible logical structures, of all possible patterns. The range …

31 October 2012

Badger jabs

From Martyn Vaughan

It is not the case that "farmers in England and Wales are keen to get on with the controversial cull" of badgers (20 October, p 8) . No cull was planned in Wales: instead the Welsh government has opted for a trial vaccination program.

31 October 2012

Genetically mollified

From Colin Johnston

Michael Marshall's article fails to address the major concerns of those of us who are alarmed at the roll-out of GM crops (13 October, p 8) . My summary of these concerns includes: the lack of real checks to counter the economic and political lobbying power of the large corporations that promote these technologies for …

31 October 2012

When is will free?

From David Holdsworth

I was struck by the relationship between the letters from Mike Pollard (6 October, p 30) , who believes we need to accept carbon capture and storage as the pivotal technology to combat climate change, and Joe Muggs (p 30) , who wonders whether we can identify those crucial decisions in life that define our …

31 October 2012

Primate play plan

From Andy Howe

Your look at animal memory mentioned Santino the chimp, who collects and hides rocks to later throw at zoo visitors (6 October, p 34) . This reminded me of a visit to a French zoo, where the chimps were in a glass enclosure, the glass panels held in place between steel columns, with small gaps …

31 October 2012

I remember you

From Peter Paterson

My autobiographical memories fit the general pattern described in your feature (6 October, p 36) : I have few before the age of 5 or 6. But my wife has many memories before 5 and even one before 1. In 1980 she recounted for the first time a memory of being held in her mother's …

31 October 2012

Sequencing loophole

From Michael Leonard

You report the US Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues as concluding: "policies should protect individual privacy by prohibiting unauthorized whole genome sequencing without the consent of the individual from whom the sample came" (20 October, p 5) . What, given a lawyerly reading of this, would stop sequencing of, say, 80 per …

31 October 2012

Fragile knowledge

From Les Higgins

Back in the mid-1970s (yes, I am that old) I was involved with some iconoclastic engineers and scientists. One of the issues much discussed was an impending technological dark age caused by the disparity between focusing on "application" and "knowledge" about a technology – electronics, for example. How many "computer" scientists or engineers, or indeed …

31 October 2012

Vlad the infuser

From Andrew Clifton

So, infusions of young blood keep older brains healthy – in mice, at least (20 October, p 10) . Would this suggest that Dracula, with his taste for the blood of young virgins, was on to a good thing?

31 October 2012

For the record

• We got the title of Stephen Cave's book wrong (20 October, p 40) . It is in fact Immortality: The quest to live forever and how it drives civilisation .

Issue no. 2889 published 3 November 2012

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop