Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


16 January 2013

Synaesthesia for all

From Amy S. Bouska

Your look at tapping multiple senses to enhance enjoyment of food seemed to be describing undiagnosed synaesthesia – a crossing of the senses (22/29 December 2012, p 60) . Perhaps, rather than being either synaesthetes or "normals", we all exist on a scale of greater or lesser synaesthesia. And for most people this synaesthesia could …

16 January 2013

Flintstone flicks

From Ted Rockley

I am grateful to Catherine Brahic for confirming my belief that animation is deeply embedded in the human psyche. Her wonderful article describes some of the ingenious methods that our ancestors came up with to create a sense of movement in cave art and artefacts (22/29 December 2012, p 44) . Animation predated the cinema, …

16 January 2013

A walnut would do

From Andrew Lenton

Bob Holmes explores ways of avoiding a scalding while carrying a hot drink (22/29 December 2012, p 65) . I am sure the answer to this appeared in New Scientist about 25 years ago. The solution, at least for African women carrying pots of water, is to float a coconut shell in the liquid. This …

16 January 2013

Astro-pology

From Derek Long

Feedback, and correspondent Bryn Glover, need to go back to their roots (22/29 December) . The word "astronomy" has nothing to do with naming, but everything to do with nomos – law, order, arrangement. But I agree that "astrology" might be a better word for what astronomers do.

16 January 2013

Drink to that

From Malcolm Bacchus

Your article on logician George Boolos's hardest logic puzzle ever and related problems (22/29 December 2012, p 50) reminded me of the truth teller/liar problem set by science writer Martin Gardner in 1959. Readers had to find the correct road to a village by asking one question of a liar or truth teller, knowing the …

16 January 2013

Gut reaction

From Caroline Herzenberg

Your look at the influence of the enteric nervous system notes that a lot of the information the gut sends to the brain affects well-being, but not in a conscious way (15 December 2012, p 38) . Perhaps the subconscious " gut instincts" and "gut reactions" that we experience may involve not just us, but …

16 January 2013

Seeing red

From Vernon C. Barber

Your report on detecting longer wavelengths of red light with a modified human visual protein (15 December 2012, p 19) suggests a way for us to see auras. If some people naturally have mutated versions of such proteins that are stimulated by infrared radiation, then the phenomenon would be possible. The editor writes: • We …

16 January 2013

Expert view

From Peter Bauer

Jeremy Howard of Kaggle, a website that hosts problem-solving competitions, champions data science over experts for solving predictive problems in many disciplines (1 December 2012, p 28) . This struck a chord, as I have found that expert knowledge can get in the way when trying to solve cutting-edge problems. But before we decide to …

16 January 2013

Blowing a fuse

From C. Leroy Ellenberger

The "electric universe" described in Greg Shanahan's letter (22/29 December 2012, p 41) is a misconception supported with naive analogies to laboratory plasma effects, and refuted by the vast majority of astronomers. He mentions physicist Anthony Peratt as a proponent. But Peratt accepts the standard model for thermonuclear stars and has disavowed the idea of …

16 January 2013

Language loss

From Duncan Cameron

Why do so many languages coexist in some parts of the world (8 December 2012, p 38) ? Most languages, like many species, become extinct, making the history of language, especially how it dies out, a bit of a sketchy affair. However, I believe when states form they squeeze out small languages. Regions of the …

16 January 2013

Mosquito Nobel

From Ullrich Fischer

You reported research online showing how the mosquito avoids infection by the malaria parasite as it passes through its body ( 11 December 2012, newscientist.com ), with talk of bioengineering its immune system to prevent transmission altogether. If this can be made to work in mosquitoes and leads to a series of attacks on other …

16 January 2013

More than ice

From Tom Groves

You told the tale of research during the second world war on ships made of ice under the guise of Project Habbakuk (22/29 December 2012, p 63) . I suspect it was a cover for wider work. When at the National Physical Laboratory in the late 1960s, a colleague showed me a film labelled Project …

16 January 2013

Bitter lesson

From Donald A. Sands

How ironic that coffee should become a victim of global warming, considering that its export worldwide is one of the causes (5 January, p 33) . The mass transportation of products across the planet has a huge carbon footprint, and is a major contributor to climate change.

16 January 2013

For the record

• In the map to accompany our look at how to protect New York from storm flooding (5 January, p 6) we wrongly labelled the Bayonne and Jersey City area as Manhattan.

Issue no. 2900 published 19 January 2013

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop