Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


31 December 2013

Smell of fear

From Stephen Durnford

Linda Geddes reports that mice can inherit a fear response via epigenetic changes – chemical changes to the DNA that can turn genes on and off (7 December, p 10) . Exposure of the father or grandfather to an odour and an electric shock resulted in offspring that were more jumpy in the presence of …

31 December 2013

Smell of fear

From Chris Good

I am perplexed. We were all toilet trained and taught our mother tongue, and so were generations of our ancestors, yet we still have to teach our children so many skills. Where did we go wrong? Were we not punished enough for failure to learn? Should we bring back the birch and strong smells? It …

31 December 2013

Hands off

From Ailsa Mathiessen

I find John Crowhurst's letter proposing Australia's outback as a dumping ground for the world's nuclear waste offensive (30 November, p 33) . It is arrogant to ignore the original inhabitants of this land, who continue to live there. We really don't want this country used as a dumping ground for any form of waste, …

31 December 2013

We're all different

From Ray Merewether

David Whitebread and Sue Bingham argue against accepting children into formal schooling at young ages as if children make up a single entity (16 November, p 28) . Nothing could be further from the truth. Some children can read books aimed at 7 to 8-year-olds at the age of 3. Some will never learn to …

31 December 2013

Slippery slope

From Norman Gregory

Your analysis of talk of a slowdown in global warming (7 December, p 34) misses what seems an obvious factor – the latent heat of fusion of melting ice. It takes about 40 times as much energy to warm water from -0.5 °C to 0.5 °C as it does to go from 1 °C to …

31 December 2013

Slippery slope

From Simon O

As I bought my copy of New Scientist with the front cover asking: "Is it time to stop worrying about climate change?", a typhoon Haiyan appeal envelope from the British Red Cross fell out. The answer, in short, is no. London, UK

31 December 2013

Haunting thought

From Rick Bradford

I suspect the discomfort that most people feel at the notion that they are "just" their physical brain is due to an insufficient respect for matter (30 November, p 30) . Physicists know that matter isn't the lumpen stuff we usually take it for. The closer you look at matter the more it dissolves before …

31 December 2013

Safer cycling

From Ian Chapple

An important point was missed when discussing cycling safety in London and the Netherlands (30 November, p 14) . As more people cycle, there is an increased likelihood that those who drive cars are also cyclists. In the Netherlands there is a small core of drivers who never ride a bike, and a small number …

31 December 2013

One-upmanship?

From Wiebina Heesterman

Keith Hudson's letter talks about a "keeping up with the Joneses" attitude among individuals as being beneficial at the group level as it boosts economies (7 December, p 32) . But what about considering the influence of "powering down with the Joneses" to help fix the climate? Just challenge the neighbours: "We use far less …

31 December 2013

Strange idea

From Adrian Bowyer

The material at the centre of a neutron star isn't stable except under star-mass gravity – it decays into everyday matter as some of the electrons and protons separate out. But now lower energy strange-quark matter is hypothesised to form in a collapsing neutron star (7 December, p 42) . If it is indeed lower …

31 December 2013

Need for speed

From Nathaniel Hellerstein

Jessica Griggs revealed an inconvenient truth about conservationists in her look at the role synthetic biology could play in that field (7 December, p 46) : they were "wary of synthetic biology being used as a convenient quick fix" in place of the harder task of changing people's behaviour. A convenient quick fix? As opposed, …

31 December 2013

Hit a brick wall

From Colin Gray

Your article on the addition of waste brewery grain to the brick-making process and the advantages this brought was very interesting (30 November, p 23) . I was involved in a similar trial several years ago using steam-sterilised cellulose fibre from municipal waste as an additive. This also improved the strength and thermal efficiency of …

31 December 2013

Long live Gaia

From Liam O

I agree with the letter from Ken Steele, that the Gaia hypothesis isn't outdated (7 December, p 32) . However, rather than having "humanity cancer" I would say Gaia has a parasitic infection. And so the question we need to ask is will the parasite destroy its host, and itself in the process, or will …

31 December 2013

Too hot to handle

From Clive Semmens

Julien Glazier refers to Fergus Gibb's idea of packaging the hottest nuclear waste into tungsten capsules and letting them melt their way down through the Earth's crust (7 December, p 32) . Surely if our hottest nuclear waste was really as (thermally) hot as that, and would remain so for a protracted period, we wouldn't …

31 December 2013

Pre-Darwin

From David Ehrenfeld

If Alfred Russel Wallace and Patrick Matthew both deserve credit for the theory of evolution alongside Charles Darwin (23 November, p 34) , what about the Baghdadi scholar al-Jahiz? In the 9th century, 1000 years before Darwin, al-Jahiz wrote in his vast Book of Animals : "Animals that survive to breed can pass on their …

31 December 2013

For the record

• In the article on the pace of global warming, we reversed the wind directions during El Niño and La Niña episodes (7 December, p 34) . During La Niña the winds are easterly, and vice versa.

Issue no. 2950 published 4 January 2014

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop