Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


5 March 2014

The drugs do work

From Martin McAlpine

I found Clare Wilson's feature on the treatment of schizophrenia very interesting ( 8 February, p 32) . I have lived with the illness for more than 30 years. Rather than being forced to continue antipsychotic medication once I was discharged from hospital, I made a rational and I think well-thought-out decision to do so. …

5 March 2014

Smoke on the water

From Steve Orchard

I read your article on the impact on health of the recent floods in Bristol, UK ( 22 February, p 7) , and was reminded of a day in 1968 that no one who lived or worked in the city will forget. I was working in Bedminster, in one of the low-lying areas. It rained …

5 March 2014

Wet future

From Mike Childs

Adam Corner's excellent article identified the psychological and cultural challenges to enabling a rational discussion on climate change ( 22 February, p 28) . But he mistakenly suggested that the message for communicators to send is "that more flooding is on the way for the UK if ambitious action on climate change is not forthcoming". …

5 March 2014

Slug appeal

From Gerald Legg

I fully support Lachlan Jones's comments on the conservation of oft-ignored creepy crawlies ( 15 February, p 34) . These often dull, brown, tiny and secretive critters should receive at least as much attention as the more charismatic species. After all, their place at the bottom of the ecological web means they support those more …

5 March 2014

Cull disgust

From Peter Monck

I have spent some time thinking about a response to your reporting of the culling of Marius the giraffe ( 15 February, p 7) . Make no mistake, animal rights protesters were not the only people to be dismayed by this action. I am not an animal rights protester, nor are most of my friends …

5 March 2014

Robot rescue

From Bill Courtney

In order to reduce flooding, Hannah Cloke at the University of Reading, UK, suggests that we need to slow down the rate at which water enters our rivers ( 15 February, p 6) . Perhaps the development of robot tractors, which New Scientist has reported on over the years, could provide part of the answer. …

5 March 2014

Dementia debate

From Chris Burke

Mark Cox's letter about the decline in dementia rates contains the unjustifiably broad statement that high levels of corticosteroids cause the damage in vascular dementia and Alzheimer's ( 15 February, p 35) . The statement has little meaning, since "corticosteroids" means steroids produced by the adrenal cortex, including adrenal androgens, mineralocorticoids, such as aldosterone, and …

5 March 2014

Patently bad

From Edward Syperek

I found David Cooper's article on changes to European patent law illuminating ( 15 February, p 32) . A question arises that I have never had a good answer to: if the aim is to foster invention, why do patents grant a monopoly, rather than an obligatory licensing fee so that others can use a …

5 March 2014

From Frank Fahy

You reported on potatoes genetically modified to resist blight ( 22 February, p 6) . I have been growing the non-GM Hungarian variety Sarpo Mira for the past four years. Even when the potatoes in neighbouring allotment plots had severe blight in 2012, my crop stood strong and green until late in the season. It …

5 March 2014

Broken hearts

Your thought-provoking interview with cognitive scientist and ethicist Brian D. Earp about a cure for love was good ( 15 February, p 27) , but would have been improved by including a consideration of the various stages of grief: shock, denial, anger, bargaining or negotiation, depression and acceptance. The lengths of these stages probably depend …

5 March 2014

Cave doodles

From Andrew Jenkins

Various explanations for the abstract patterns of dots and lines that have been found alongside cave paintings ( 23 November 2013, p 36) have been suggested by your readers. Modern humans also draw random patterns of dots and lines. It's called "doodling". I suggest that the cave artist was trying to stay awake during a …

5 March 2014

Well blended

From Martin Edwardes

Mark Turner's theory that humans differ from animals because they produce new ideas by blending old ones has two important issues ( 22 February, p 30) . First, the capacity to blend ideas appears much earlier in the fossil record than the Upper Palaeolithic. Jayne Wilkins of Arizona State University has shown that hominins seemed …

5 March 2014

No hole

From Mats Bergenhov

Despite articles by Lisa Grossman ( 8 February, p 8) and Marcus Chown ( p 41) and all other stories about black holes – there are no holes in the universe. There are irregularities, pits, whirls and so on, but no holes. So I suggest the black hole needs renaming. A black pit, maybe? Malmõ, …

5 March 2014

For the record

• We were out of order to suggest bees, wasps and ants belong to the same family in our article on insect pheromones ( 25 January, p 17) . They all belong to the same order, Hymenoptera.

Issue no. 2959 published 8 March 2014

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop