Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


21 June 2023

Grappling with imminent prospect of scary warming (1)

From Trevor Prew, Sheffield, UK

Even with 1.5°C of warming on the very near horizon, the vast majority of humanity seems to be in denial of climate change and is failing to act. Perhaps calling it climate change is part of the problem. I suggest always calling it human-induced warming or fossil fuel-induced warming, so the cause is clear ( …

21 June 2023

Grappling with imminent prospect of scary warming (2)

From Fred White, Nottingham, UK

We are at more than 424 parts per million (ppm) of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and rising. With no reference to temperatures, the chemist James Lovelock – who proposed the Gaia hypothesis – considered approaching 450 ppm to be reckless; by then, damaging, irreversible positive feedbacks would start locking into place. Unlike speculating about …

21 June 2023

Grappling with imminent prospect of scary warming (3)

From Steuart Campbell, Edinburgh, UK

You say that carbon cuts alone won't be enough to reverse catastrophic climate change. I agree. Measures introduced so far will have very little effect. Emissions continue to rise, even accelerating. This is doomsday unless something drastic is done. Fiddling with carbon capture is never going to hack it. We don't have time for such …

21 June 2023

We can talk to the animals, so chat with ET is possible (1)

From Drew Haffenden, Dauphin Island, Alabama, US

Chris Impey doubts the prospects of communicating with aliens, saying that despite sharing 99 per cent of our DNA with chimps, we can't communicate with them. However, humans have been making themselves understood by chimps for 50 years. We have been communicating with other animals, and they with us, for thousands of years ( 27 …

21 June 2023

We can talk to the animals, so chat with ET is possible (2)

From Daniel Magasanik, Melbourne, Australia

Impey doesn't mention another reason for caution in contacting aliens, even if they are assumed to be benevolent. They might freely make technologies available to us that are far more advanced than our own, thinking that they could only help us. They may assume that we don't suffer from the dysfunction and conflicts that plague …

21 June 2023

We can talk to the animals, so chat with ET is possible (3)

From David Myers, Commugny, Switzerland

The reason we can't communicate with chimps is because they aren't sufficiently intelligent, but this has no bearing whatsoever on whether we could communicate with an alien species clever enough to detect our messages.

21 June 2023

AI in movies will be theatre's gain

From Tony Budd, Wickford, Essex, UK

Regarding negotiations between actors in the US and the film industry over the use of artificial intelligence to mimic performers on screen, it seems to me that if this technology takes over film, TV and online drama, then there will be a huge boost for live theatre. Seeing real actors on stage will be everybody's …

21 June 2023

Growing brains in a dish does raise many issues

From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France

Michael Le Page says that brain organoids grown in labs are nothing like real brains, that they are "bunches of brain cells just a few millimetres across that are nowhere near even a simple animal brain" ( 10 June, p 21 ). Even so, that is a lot bigger than many animal brains. The whole …

21 June 2023

Changing stance is heartbreaking to see

From Karen Dawn, DawnWatch, an animal advocacy charity, Santa Barbara, California, US

Though it is great to see animal issues covered in New Scientist , it is heartbreaking to see Peter Singer, who was once a great voice for animals, even contemplating the idea that their farming and humane slaughter might be considered ethical ( 3 June, p 43 ). Can you imagine Gloria Steinem discussing types …

21 June 2023

Don't just freeze your head, but faeces too

From Keith Thomas, Richmond, North Yorkshire, UK

While not wishing to promote the freezing of heads more than sense dictates, it did occur to me that a severed head isn't just missing the rest of its natural form, but also its microbiome – increasingly recognised as an additional dimension of health and personality. To partially compensate for this, perhaps a frozen head …

21 June 2023

Pack it in please, supermarkets

From Martin Pitt, Leeds, UK

I do believe a basic bag-filling algorithm, of the sort described by Peter Rowlett as "a simple rule a computer program can mindlessly apply", is already being used by the supermarkets that deliver to my home. Considering no factor other than filling space, sliced bread is routinely squashed out of all recognition by bottles, jars …

Issue no. 3444 published 24 June 2023

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop