Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


1 November 2023

Is a diet of microgreens really worth the effort?

From Roy Gray, Macclesfield, Cheshire, UK

Microgreens may have a high density of nutrients and vitamins, but does the body absorb them all? Maybe the extras end up in the waste stream. It would be good to know how their absorption compares with that of "normal" diced raw carrots, for instance ( 14 October, p 36 ).

1 November 2023

Rearing carnivores for meat is senseless

From John Kitchen, Kettering, Northamptonshire, UK

On the subject of sea-farmed salmon, why do we farm carnivorous fish when, to produce 1 kilogram of them, we require a much greater weight of wild-caught fish? There is really no excuse, either environmental or economic, for doing so ( 21 October, p 20 ).

1 November 2023

On the rise of the new forms of AI

From Nick Hunn, London, UK

Further to Alex Wilkins's piece on how large language models (LLMs) are similar to codec compression algorithms like MP3: despite the knowledge that MP3 lowered audio quality, users flocked to it, resulting in the music streaming industry of today. Convenience trumped quality. It seems the same thing will happen with LLMs ( 7 October, p …

1 November 2023

Science isn't just for the gifted few

From Anthony Forbes, Durban, South Africa

The comment from a local politician that most politicians are "people persons" and aren't versed in science is both condemnatory and horrifying. Science isn't some mystic process restricted to a gifted few. It ultimately comes down to rational, logical thought where decisions are based on real information, not gut feelings. If it is really the …

1 November 2023

Dancing fruit and nuts have a long history

From Dave Appleby, Eastbourne, East Sussex, UK

Your article reports research about nuts and raisins "dancing" in carbonated liquids. I taught school students to observe this phenomenon in the 1980s – I believe I found the experiment in the publications of the Nuffield Science Project ( 7 October, p 17 ). Your account of what happens doesn't mention the fact that when …

1 November 2023

There is only one substance that falls up (1)

From Joseph Majewski, Rindge, New Hampshire, US

The article "Antimatter definitely doesn't fall up, physicists confirm" brings to mind the element upsidaisium from the Rocky and Bullwinkle cartoons ( 7 October, p 16 ).

1 November 2023

There is only one substance that falls up (2)

From John Henderson, St Marys, Ontario, Canada

The only substance that falls up is upsidaisium, a metal found only in the floating Mount Flatten. The ill-intentioned Mr Big assigned his top agents to steal Mount Flatten. Happily, Rocky and Bullwinkle were able to protect the world's upsidaisium supply.

1 November 2023

I agree, non-native plants can be a boon

From Stephen Head, Cholsey, Oxfordshire, UK

James Wong casts his habitual common sense on the issue of native and non-native garden plants. Yes, "alien" plants can be a disaster in unique ecosystems like the South African fynbos, but the UK's sparse flora has only 1625 native species compared with 1798 aliens established as unthreatening wildflowers ( 30 September, p 44 ). …

1 November 2023

Why the Wood Age won't quite cut it

From Mark Kaminsky, Sunnyvale, California, US

The story "Earliest evidence of wood buildings" ends by saying "we might need to rethink our labelling of the Stone Age", that it was maybe "more of a wood age" ( 30 September, p 14 ). My understanding is that the various ages (Stone, Bronze and Iron) were named for the most common material used …

1 November 2023

Let's keep an open mind on alien communication

From Ben Haller, Ithaca, New York, US

I was a bit shocked to read Raymond Hickey's dismissal of the circle-writing by aliens that visit Earth in the movie Arrival . He says no animal "would use such a short-supply resource as their ink for primary communication". Why assume that it was even their own ink? Or maybe their own ink isn't, for …

1 November 2023

What to call the opening age of the Anthropocene

From Bryn Glover, Kirkby Malzeard, North Yorkshire, UK

As discussions about a possible Anthropocene Epoch continue, it occurs to me that these seem to ignore the fact that we may need to name a new geological "age" too. The Holocene has three: Greenlandian, Northgrippian and Meghalayan ( Letters, 30 September ). One proposal is that the Anthropocene began in around 1750, which is …

Issue no. 3463 published 4 November 2023

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop