Letters archive
Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
29 January 2025
From Paul Friedlander, London, UK
Reader views on the colonisation of Mars, varied as they have been, have missed the most important point of all. Historically, colonisation was driven by a search for opportunities to trade and get rich. Perhaps, with Elon Musk as one of the chief proponents, we are missing the elephant in the room. Rather than debating …
29 January 2025
From Robert Masta, Ann Arbor, Michigan, US
"Bursting the bubble", about quantum ideas that could do away with the multiverse, was excellent, but it is troubling that theorists still consider Schrödinger's cat and Wigner's friend to be valid thought experiments. They assume that a human observer is required for quantum collapse, which is absurd ( 11 January, p 32 ). How did …
29 January 2025
From Jim Moore, Coelbren, Powys, UK
James Wong's verdict on the poor efficacy of banana skins as plant fertiliser was spot on. However, it is likely that the widely reported benefits attributed to banana skins for gardeners are down to their polyphenol content ( 11 January, p 44 ). It has been shown that an application of polyphenols can act as …
29 January 2025
From Jim McHardy, Clydebank, West Dunbartonshire, UK
If quantum computers are accessing the multiverse, as Hartmut Neven suggests, then we must assume that aliens in parallel universes could also have quantum computers. They must also be aware of their making use of other universes' quantum computers. Could this make us lab rats for their experiments( 4 January, p 40 )?
29 January 2025
From Steve Archbold, Chichester, West Sussex, UK
The report that blinking gives your brain a break by taking pauses while reading reminds me of the views of Hollywood film editor Walter Murch in his 1992 book In the Blink of an Eye ( 11 January, p 17 ). He says the difference between a good actor and a bad one is in …
29 January 2025
From Dave Covell, Ottery St Mary, Devon, UK
As an energy/carbon engineer for over 35 years, I fully support the "defossilisation" of production of goods. However, why the fixation on capturing carbon from the flue gas of blast furnaces or other hot and highly polluted sources( 4 January, p 22 )? In my career, I have encountered many manufacturing processes, including acid neutralisation …
29 January 2025
From John Theophilus, Bream, Gloucestershire, UK
As I understand it, "Backwards computing" asserted that the bulk of heat emitted by computers arises from changes to information in the process of doing calculations. Does this apply to other media? How about a sheet of paper on which difficult sums had been written( 28 December 2024, p 38 )?
29 January 2025
From Jim Ainsworth, Kingsland, Herefordshire, UK
You ask if Santa's festive surveillance brings about an improvement in children's behaviour. A 6-year-old granddaughter was being encouraged to behave particularly well in the run-up to Christmas because Santa is all-seeing. When she encountered actual Santa in his grotto, he, not having been properly briefed, made the mistake of asking her whether or not …