Subscribe now

Letter: Letter: Puzzling preserves

Published 27 January 1990

From J D WALTER

I was interested to read Alun Rees’s article about the life of pickled
onions (Forum, 23/30 December). About 10 years ago I asked a leading manufacturer
whether its bottled sauces would keep better if refrigerated. It said emphatically
that the natural preservatives in its products were adequate without refrigeration,
which may even cause curdling.

A few years later I noticed that these products said ‘Refrigerate after
opening’ on the labels. The ingredients list had not changed so I asked
the manufacturer why it was now giving such opposite advice. It gave me
a very muddled reply but assured me that the keeping properties of its products
without refrigeration had not changed.

So why the change of label? I was told that most consumers associated
‘freshness’ with the need to refrigerate but that I would not notice any
change in quality if I continued to store the products as I had done for
the past 20 years.

Maybe the answer to Rees’s question regarding a short life after opening
is that the consumer now associates short life with ‘freshness’. I can’t
imagine why any manufacturer would want its customers to throw perfectly
good food away, forcing them to buy more. For myself, if it looks, smells
and tastes good then I eat it.

J. D. Walter Woking, Surrey

Issue no. 1701 published 27 January 1990

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop