Subscribe now

Letter: Letters: Battery bashing

Published 25 April 1992

From MICHAEL BELL

I don’t know the answer to Jonathan Wallace’s question (Letters, 28
March) as to whether nickel-cadmium batteries should be run down fully or
only part way, but either way I know what to do about it.

If you drop a ‘tired’ battery about a foot onto a concrete floor a few
times it renews the battery wonderfully. The theory (folklore?) is that
a layer of crystals builds up around the electrodes and dropping the battery
breaks the crystals.

Whatever the truth of the theory, it certainly works.

Michael Bell Hitchin, Hertfordshire

* * *

Editor’s note: We have heard that in some cases this does work. But
be careful – you may cause the battery to leak, which could damage your
equipment. As to Wallace’s question, the advice we received from battery
experts is that Ni-Cd batteries should be completely discharged before charging,
but lead-acid batteries should be regularly topped up with charge.

Issue no. 1818 published 25 April 1992

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop