Subscribe now

Letter: Letters : Phoning home

Published 13 September 1997

From Charles Mackay

Inverness, Scotland

I would like to add some of my own speculation about the Wow signal
(“Wow! was that ET?”, 9 August, p 46).
Supposing the signal did not originate from a
human source and was not an astrophysical phenomenon, but came from an
extraterrestrial civilisation. If it required a 2.2 gigawatt transmitter, would
that not suggest a civilisation more advanced than our own?

Let’s suppose that the Wow signal was not meant for us, but was transmitted
by Civilisation A to Civilisation B somewhere towards the Galactic centre. The
transmitting power used suggests Civilisation A may be capable of interstellar
spaceflight and B could therefore either be another civilisation or a
colony.

Such a message may have been transmitted hundreds or thousands of years ago,
and only received by us now. Having received it, I believe we should be
returning a signal ourselves, perhaps by repeating the unmodulated blast of
radio noise together with a message of our own.

For all those who say ET has not been in touch, the truth is that we may have
missed our chance to eavesdrop on a long-distance telephone conversation, one
that stretches light years across the Galaxy.

Issue no. 2099 published 13 September 1997

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop