Subscribe now

Letter: Right but rejected

Published 22 May 1999

From Andrew Brierley

We should not perhaps be surprised that Randolf Raff and his colleagues were
able to cross-fertilise two sea urchin species that diverged 10 million years ago
(This Week, 17 April, p 7).

Donald Williamson has reported the development of a hybrid larva from a sea
squirt egg (Ascidia mentula, phylum Chordata) fertilised with
sperm of the sea-urchin (Echinus esculentus, phylum
Echinodermata).

So unorthodox were Williamson’s observations that his paper “Incongruous
larvae and the origins of some invertebrate life histories” was rejected by
seven journals before finally being published in 1988 (Progress in
Oceanography, vol 19, p 87).

The paper also reports that embryonic and larval forms have occasionally been
transferred between distinct evolutionary lineages as a result of
cross-fertilisations.

Bourn, Cambridge

Issue no. 2187 published 22 May 1999

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop