Subscribe now

Letter: Letter

Published 25 December 1999

From Jim Lawton

Your article gave me an idea for a way to achieve correct pitch which I have
not seen mentioned elsewhere.

It had not struck me before that people using tonal languages are actually
operating on absolute rather than relative pitch. We must sound very monotonous
to them! Not only that, but each of us speaking a non-tonal language adopts his
or her own “monotone”, that is, the pitch of my and anyone else’s voice does not
vary from day to day.

I am an amateur singer, and as the article correctly points out, many singers
and musicians without perfect pitch are able to correctly pitch melodies in
relation to a given start note. It is achieving the start note which is the
problem.

After reading the article, I realised that my natural speaking voice is
pitched at E. I then made myself a phrase, “This is the pitch for meeeeeeeee”,
and having spoken it, I can find any other start note I want relative to my
native E.

Leeds

Issue no. 2218 published 25 December 1999

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop