Subscribe now

Letter: Right to spy

Published 8 April 2000

From Evan Stanbury

You state that the human rights group Liberty is concerned about commercial
organisations making it possible to eavesdrop on satellite telephone calls
(11 March, p 15).
In fact, all countries have laws allowing phone-tapping in case of serious crime.

No police force would want to permit a communications system to operate that
prevented it from solving crimes, as such a system would attract criminals.
Motorola, the originator of the patent mentioned in the article, was not
offering to set up a commercial spy service, but merely showing that a satellite
telephone service can support national laws.

This just leaves the difficult task of determining which nations have
jurisdiction over a particular satellite call, given that in Europe the
satellite may pass over two or three nations in the course of a single call, and
that the call may be routed via satellites over entirely different nations.

Roselands, New South Wales

Issue no. 2233 published 8 April 2000

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop