Subscribe now

Letter: Letter

Published 13 May 2000

From John Carney

Anyone who argues that 747s, combs and coffee cups are complex systems not
produced by random forces, therefore complex systems cannot be produced by
random forces, is in no position to criticise anyone else’s reasoning. I would
advise Tom Willis to go back to school and brush up on the fundamentals of
logic. He might also benefit from contemplating a snowflake.

Moreover, Darwinism does not lead to eugenics, which hinged on a value
judgement (that some humans are better than others) with no scientific basis.
Nor does eugenics lead automatically to mass slaughter. One doesn’t see horses
being rounded up and shot because they’re not quite up to racing calibre. The
Holocaust was not the consequence of a philosophy rooted in Darwinism.

john.carney@pacific.net.au

Issue no. 2238 published 13 May 2000

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop