Subscribe now

Letter: Weeping reactors

Published 15 September 2001

From Artur Knoth

Regarding the new Japanese design for a small nuclear reactor, I beg to
differ with the assessment of one of the “experts” stating that there was
nothing wrong with the basic design
(25 August, p 4).

Molten sodium cooling systems have a “weeping” problem, where the fluid tends
to squeeze through even the finest micro-cracks in materials. Whenever this
cooling material encounters water, the reaction is violent and explosive.

Also, less than 10 per cent of natural lithium is the isotope lithium-6. This
would require costly isotopic separation from the more common lithium-7.
Lithium-6 is used in nuclear bombs and if it got into the wrong hands could be
as dangerous as enriched uranium and reactor plutonium.

When lithium-6 captures a neutron, it can decay into tritium and helium.
Tritium is radioactive and can easily enter biological systems in water.

I’d say there’s quite a lot wrong with the concept of a small nuclear
reactor, and without stringent safeguards it could become an environmental and
proliferation hazard of the first order, especially in a country subjected to
numerous earthquakes and typhoons.

Immenstaad, Germany

Issue no. 2308 published 15 September 2001

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop