Subscribe now

Letter: Ball with a view

Published 5 June 2004

From Timothy Campbell

Your Invention column describes a patent for marking a ball with a pattern of 55 dots in five colours, which will present a unique appearance at every possible angle (8 May, p 23). This sounded unnecessarily complex to me, so I pulled out an orange and marked the surface into eight “triangular” sections, or octants. I then painted it red, yellow, green and blue.

It doesn’t matter which way you turn this ball, you always get a unique view. Am I missing something important about that bespeckled ball mentioned in your column? Or should I be contacting a patent attorney, since my ball apparently does what theirs does, and it is much prettier (see www.tc123.com/rotaball.gif).

The editor writes:

• To be fair to the inventors, they do say in their long and complicated patent that solutions with fewer markings are possible and the invention also applies to non-spherical balls with irregular shapes.

Toronto, Canada

Issue no. 2450 published 5 June 2004

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop