Subscribe now

Letter: I am me

Published 28 September 2005

From Geoff Lane

If my ID card contains an “identity” based on some biometric to do with my body, why do I need to carry an ID card?

I am me. I carry my body around wherever I go. Why do I need an ID card that merely duplicates the information and is so easily lost or stolen?

To be useful the cards have to be compared to a known copy of the data on some central system and then the biometric data has to be measured on my body and compared. The card is a pointless, error-prone additional step.

Duncan Graham-Rowe writes:

• If you have no card and scan just, say, the iris, the only way to identify someone is to search a massive database for an iris that matches. This is a one-to-many match, which is a lot more demanding than simply doing a one-to-one match with a single biometric template of an iris stored on the card, and more prone to error.

Bury, Greater Manchester, UK

Issue no. 2519 published 1 October 2005

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop