Subscribe now

Letter: Puzzle answered

Published 30 August 2006

From Stuart Semmens

I read Stephanie Pain’s article on ancient Chinese mathematics with interest, but I can’t figure out the initial problem about the fox, the wildcat and the dog (29 July, p 50).

What is the answer, and how is it arrived at?

Stephanie Pain writes:

• If the cat’s skin is worth twice the dog’s and the fox’s worth twice the cat’s, then the dog pays one-seventh of the total, the cat two-sevenths and the fox four-sevenths. Divide the total amount owed (“111 cash”) by seven, to give the dog’s share (15 and 6/7ths cash). Multiply this by two to give the cat’s share (31 and 5/7ths cash), and by four for the fox’s (63 and 3/7ths cash).

Selby, Victoria, Australia

Issue no. 2567 published 2 September 2006

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop