Subscribe now

Letter: Replacing resources

Published 20 June 2007

From Rolf Clayton

David Cohen paints a pessimistic picture of the world’s remaining resources of a number of industrially important metals such as platinum, gallium and indium (26 May, p 34). However, the article did not explore sufficiently the possibility of exploiting the single largest resource of a wide range of industrially valuable metals – the sea.

For example, you gave world resources of copper as 937 million tonnes, yet there are around 1350 million tonnes in the sea; for gold the figures are 89,700 tonnes and 1.8 million tonnes in the sea; for indium 6000 tonnes and 9000 million tonnes; for uranium 3.3 million tonnes and 1350 million tonnes.

About 30 to 40 years ago a number of papers were published that examined the possibility of recovering metals from the sea, using ion-exchange technology. The proposal was that barrages, such as one across the UK’s Severn estuary, could incorporate huge banks of selective ion-exchangers that would selectively remove gold, uranium and other metals from the seawater. This would have achieved two objectives: the generation of tidal power and the recovery of industrially valuable metals.

Perhaps now is the time to go back to the past and re-evaluate these ideas.

London, UK

Issue no. 2609 published 23 June 2007

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop