Subscribe now

Letter: Underground nukes

Published 28 March 2012

From Bry Lynas

Fred Pearce brings home the sheer complexity of decommissioning nuclear reactors (10 March, p 46). With 138 shut down and many more to come, it is quite a legacy.

Yet there is a solution for future generations of nuclear plants: build all reactors and their primary cooling circuits underground. Decommissioning would then involve little more than sealing the entrance and walking away. The non-radioactive surface plant could be removed like any other obsolete building or industrial structure.

If decommissioning costs were truly factored in to the lifetime cost of a plant, the higher initial outlay would be fully justified. Pearce talks of costs of half a billion dollars to decommission one reactor, and a decommissioning by-product of half a million tonnes of radioactive waste from a German plant.

Llangybi, Gwynedd, UK

Issue no. 2858 published 31 March 2012

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop