Subscribe now

Letter: Data fudging begins at school

Published 29 June 2016

From Bill Courtney

A teenage reader related the creation of false experimental data by school science students (Letters, 4 June). I can assure younger readers that there is nothing new about this.

Back in 1964, my A-level physics practical examination required finding the local acceleration due to gravity, g, using the swinging pendulum method. At that time both metric and imperial units were on the syllabus.

Knowledgeable students were aware that g could be taken as either 981 centimetres per second squared or 32 feet per second squared. When we left the exam room, one of my friends boasted that he would probably be awarded full marks for this practical paper. Instead of “wasting time” doing the experiment, he had used his slide rule to create a beautiful straight-line graph. This might have impressed the examiner, had the value not been hopelessly inaccurate because the poor lad had got his imperial and metric units muddled up.

He failed the A-level physics exam and I have no idea what his subsequent career was.

Altrincham, Cheshire, UK

Issue no. 3080 published 2 July 2016

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop