Subscribe now

Letter: Why do relatives have a veto on organ wishes?

Published 12 September 2018

From Douglas Nichols, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia

You report that an “opt-out” system for organ donation could reduce transplant rates, as relatives are less confident their late family member agreed and so may be more likely to veto donation (25 August, p 16).

I have always wondered why families are permitted to veto an individual's decision about organ donation. They aren't allowed to veto instructions on the distribution of assets after death, as specified in a will. Remove the ability for families to veto and the potential problems of the opt-out system would vanish. If that can't be done, we could allow a veto for opt-out cases unless the individual concerned has specifically – and optionally – indicated a wish to donate.

Issue no. 3195 published 15 September 2018

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop