Subscribe now

Letter: Hand weeding really isn't effective for most crops

Published 24 July 2019

From Mary Rose, Goolwa, South Australia

Discussing superweeds, you say that hand weeding crops is effective, though costly (22 June, p 12). But it can be effective only for crops grown in narrow rows with wide spaces between rows that people can walk along. Otherwise the weeders will trample the crop.

Some vegetables are grown like this. But here in Australia, commercial crops of cereals, oil seeds, field legumes and grass for hay are grown in a way that leaves no room for hand weeding.

A wheat crop could have 100 plants per square metre and 50 seedlings of the weed annual ryegrass per square metre. Not only would the wheat be trampled by hand weeding, but I suspect it would take more energy to weed than the crop would produce. Are there enough people in the world to weed the extensive areas that the world now farms to feed us all?

Issue no. 3240 published 27 July 2019

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop