Subscribe now

Letter: Still wrestling with the meaty issue

Published 25 May 2022

From Philip Belben, Nettlebridge, Somerset, UK

Helen Senior is right to say we need a new name for “lab-grown meat”, but I disagree that existing terms are “unscientific” or that “synthetic foodstuffs” would be a better term (Letters, 14 May). These foods are grown from animal cells cultured in a facility (currently a laboratory, but in future, probably a factory). They are therefore arguably “animal flesh”, but hardly “synthetic”.

New inventions often face this problem. When a new term is needed, either a new word is coined, like automobile or flashlight, or an existing word is co-opted, like car or torch. If confusion arises with other uses of the word, a qualifier is added: motor car, or electric torch. This is what is currently being done with “lab-grown meat” – and it is the accuracy of “lab-grown” that is questionable, not the word “meat”.

Issue no. 3388 published 28 May 2022

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop