Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


30 November 2022

Could a cyclical universe trump the multiverse?

From Nigel Tuersley, Wardour, Wiltshire, UK

In your interview with Roger Penrose, he points out that "nobody knows where the fundamental constants of nature come from". The sheer improbability of their being so finely tuned for life has given rise to the multiverse hypothesis where, by a process you might call cosmological selection, life and consciousness only come to exist in …

30 November 2022

Let the oil giants fund loss and damage payments

From Chris Lee, Stokesby, Norfolk, UK

Your article discusses the possibility of "loss and damage" payments by higher-income nations to lower-income ones suffering as a result of climate change. I fully support such reparations, but suggest they should be paid by fossil fuel firms( 19 November, p 8 ). These companies continue to plan expansion and further damage, have made huge …

30 November 2022

Why we may never get to grips with climate change

From Lloyd Timberlake, Ridge, Maryland, US

Almost all coverage of climate change ignores the horrendous reality that we will not and cannot manage this challenge. This is because we won't make major sacrifices for future generations, whose interests have little to no place in our institutions, especially our legal systems( 12 November, p 7 ). It is in neither the political …

30 November 2022

Let's just scrap daylight saving instead

From Talia Morris, Cape Tribulation, Queensland, Australia

In your article on daylight saving, you suggest that by making daylight saving permanent in the US, excess human and deer deaths caused by the annual shift in clocks could be eliminated. This is possibly true, but I think eliminating daylight saving altogether would be a healthier and more sustainable option. It is very likely …

30 November 2022

Red street lamps may not be so great, after all

From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France

Two recent letters have advocated using red LEDs for street lighting. There are two reasons not to do this. First, sodium lights are being replaced by LEDs because LEDs can give a white light that helps people to see things better at night, especially in their peripheral vision. Second, our eyes aren't as sensitive to …

30 November 2022

Mealworms are an answer to 'compostable' plastics

From Andrew Kadir-Buxton, Hatfield, Hertfordshire, UK

I read your report on problems with compostable plastic. A friend of mine tried to compost such plastic and found it didn't break down. I suggested adding some mealworms to his compost and the plastic was soon eaten. This is scalable, and perhaps the adult mealworms could be turned into pet food at the end …

30 November 2022

Time to pull the plug on big money for fusion

From Alec Mitchell, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

How is it that fusion research gets so much positive PR? I know that any research programme requires an element of optimistic taking of chances, but this whole field has the aroma of a lost cause about it - and yet we are still throwing money at fusion projects( 22 October, p 38 ). How …

30 November 2022

No drought needed for industrial revolution

From John McIntosh, Birkenhead, Merseyside, UK

You report the view that drought may have started the industrial revolution and the move away from water power. I don't buy it. The switch to steam didn't need a drought. Water power required a factory near a rivere. Steam power allowed factories anywhere, with flexible and expandable layouts. Once the economics became similar, no …

7 December 2022

The Titanic solution for stemming glacier melt

From Jim McHardy, Clydebank, West Dunbartonshire, UK

Building a curtain across the Jakobshavn glacier in Greenland – a suggestion to slow it melting – is estimated to take a minimum of 30 years and be expensive. A quick, albeit unsightly, fix would be to sink two or more large ships across the front of the glacier, which would block the influx of …

7 December 2022

Reasons why biofuels should have a role

From Guy Cox, Sydney, Australia

I totally agree with Fred White that we should get as much energy as we can from solar panels, but in playing down the potential role of biofuels, he misses two important points( Letters, 19 November ). Firstly, biofuel, once produced, is available day or night, rain or shine. Secondly, producing biofuel from algae rather …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop