Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


5 October 2022

If it was good enough for Charles Darwin...

From Stephanie Woodcock, Carnon Downs, Cornwall, UK

Mark Harper invites us to get the health benefits of swimming in cool, wild waters ( 17 September, p 25 ). Many well-known members of Victorian society flocked to the spa town of Malvern in England to consult doctors, who prescribed cold-water immersion of one type or another. Charles Darwin had such belief in his …

5 October 2022

I wish I could share optimism for the future

From Don Martin, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

It brings me joy to encounter the optimism of youth ( 10 September, p 27 ). The only statement that I disagree with in William MacAskill's article about ensuring a better world for coming generations, is that "a dystopian future is far from inevitable". My view comes after a lifetime of fighting for the exact …

5 October 2022

For the record {08 October 2022}

IBM's quantum computer fridge is 100 times colder than space ( 17 September, p 18 ). In the study of links between the pandemic and premature puberty, pre-pandemic cases were found to occur at age 7.6, on average, compared with 6.8 during the covid-19 pandemic ( 24 September, p 8 ).

12 October 2022

There is more to our pets than a bowl of food (1)

From Marc Bekoff, Boulder, Colorado, US

"Meat-free mutts and moggies" is an interesting piece that covers a detailed study by Andrew Knight and his team 24 September, p 44 . I think the simple answer to the question of whether dogs and cats can be healthy vegans is that we don't know. However, what a dog or cat eats is only …

12 October 2022

There is more to our pets than a bowl of food (2)

From Vet Pete Wedderburn, Bray, County Wicklow, Ireland

While your article made a passing reference to insect-based food as an alternative to regular meat, but with a lower environmental impact, this deserved more focus. Insect-based foods, for example food made from black soldier fly larvae, seem far more suitable for pets than plant-based products, with a more palatable and more nutritionally complete profile.

12 October 2022

Some tips if you have trouble getting to sleep

From Butch Dalrymple Smith, La Ciotat, France

You covered recent advances in treatment for insomnia 1 October, p 38 . I have two secrets for nodding off to share. When I was 8 years old, my older brother told me that complete relaxation in a darkened room for 5 hours is equivalent to 4 hours asleep. The important thing is to believe …

12 October 2022

Welcome clarity on what really shapes us (1)

From Bob Denmark, Garstang, Lancashire, UK

Thank you to Clare Wilson for a very clear account of the latest research in the nature versus nurture debate 24 September, p 36 . By the time my three kids hit their late teens, I concluded that their physical and psychological make-up was roughly one-third inherited, one-third due to the influence of family, friends …

12 October 2022

Welcome clarity on what really shapes us (2)

From Lee Seldon, Melbourne, Australia

I recall that all chemical processes in human brains – developing or developed, past, present and future – are subject to the laws of thermodynamics. That list would include gene expression, nutrition, neuronal and white matter growth and so on. Thermodynamics is a statistical description. In other words, it involves luck. That would indicate that …

12 October 2022

Welcome clarity on what really shapes us (3)

From Jon Arch, Welwyn Garden City, Hertfordshire, UK

Wilson's article on the role of randomness in shaping our children should be essential reading for parents and those who counsel them. It is a hard lesson to learn as we like to be in control.

12 October 2022

To go green, we need to ban lifestyle advertising

From Martin Murray, Telford, Shropshire, UK

I agree with Solitaire Townsend's call for green status signals, which are necessary to trigger behavioural changes that can address climate change 24 September, p 25 . I can see several hurdles that will need to be overcome. We must switch to a society where conspicuous giving and philanthropy are the main sources of status, …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop