Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


3 November 2021

Children are natural scientists until school

From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK

From your review of Ada Twist, Scientist , I am looking forward to seeing it ( 16 October, p 36 ). However, it occurred to me that young children don't need to be encouraged to be scientists. My granddaughter's second birthday is coming up and she has been engaging in increasingly sophisticated experimental investigations since …

3 November 2021

A paradoxical problem in the black hole paradox

From Frank Scott, Sydney, Australia

In his article on the black hole information paradox, Paul Davies postulates a "residual connection reaching across the event horizon" between entangled pairs of particles of Hawking radiation ( 25 September, p 34 ). One particle travels back across the event horizon of the black hole, and the other travels away. With one of the …

10 November 2021

Biting back over the vegan substitutes health trap (2)

From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France

Your article on vegan substitutes draws on flaws in dietary science that were pointed out in an article you published two years ago ( 13 July 2019 ). This showed how most dietary advice is based on observational studies rather than randomised, controlled studies, a state of affairs that leads to contradictory guidance on things …

10 November 2021

The climate crisis is just a tragedy of the commons (1)

From Tim Stevenson,Prestwood, Buckinghamshire, UK

One phrase that doesn't seem to be used enough in the context of the COP26 summit and climate change is "the tragedy of the commons" ( 30 October, p 8 ). This describes a scenario that is a standard part of mathematical game theory. The "tragedy" considers free public use of a common resource – …

10 November 2021

The climate crisis is just a tragedy of the commons

From Hillary Shaw,Newport, Shropshire, UK

Having read several pages on COP26 and the need to cut emissions, I was struck by the irony of a story on the next page reporting advances in restoring male fertility ( p 13 ). The largest contribution an individual can make to reducing carbon emissions is to not have a child.

10 November 2021

Rooting for Finland's tree-based circular economy

From Trevor Jones, Sheringham, Norfolk, UK

Graham Lawton's article "A wooden circular economy", on Finland's research and development of a cyclical symbiosis of woodlands, forestry and wood technology, was life-affirming and full of hope for the future ( 30 October, p 21 ). Finland demonstrates one way forward that embraces the beginning of a new age of wood and the coming …

10 November 2021

How to make heat pumps more attractive

From Christopher Jessop, Marloes, Pembrokeshire, UK, and Andrew Gigiel, Bridgwater, Somerset, UK

Coupled with insulation and draughtproofing, heat pumps are very good for warming buildings sustainably, but they cost more than boilers and are more complicated ( 23 October, p 9 ). While reliability is excellent, repairs by skilled technicians (if needed) are costly. And knowing how to run a heat pump optimally is difficult when some …

10 November 2021

Horse origin may shed light on a bigger mystery

From Peter Mullins, Haworth, West Yorkshire, UK

Your article on the possible origin of domesticated horses has some important wider implications ( 30 October, p 18 ). These relate to the realisation that languages as diverse as modern Welsh and classical Sanskrit have a common root, which has led to a search for the origins of a Proto-Indo-European language . There are …

10 November 2021

Issue of Indigenous land in the US runs very deep

From Lucy Roberts Wantage, Oxfordshire, UK

Regarding Annalee Newitz's look at the truth behind land used to fund some universities in the US – that is to say, the fact that it was taken from Indigenous people ( 2 October, p 26 ). My understanding is that pretty much all land in the US was stolen from these people, either by …

10 November 2021

Turn your food waste into a tasty 'rubbish soup'

From Silvia Dingwall,Nussbaumen, Switzerland

When it comes to reducing food waste, we often put vegetable peelings in a pressure cooker (a great energy-saving device) with some water, herbs and garlic to make a healthy vegetable broth we call "rubbish soup" ( 25 September, p 42 ). We keep the strained liquid and put any remaining solids in the compost, …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop