Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


4 May 2021

For the record

Conservationists will implant fertilised eggs of northern white rhinos into surrogates from the southern white rhino population ( 23 January, p 16 ).

4 May 2021

On the debate about baby formula at food banks (2)

From Kate Evans (author of

The Food of Love: Your formula for successful breastfeeding), Street, Somerset, UK Nobody wants babies to go hungry, but Wilson's contribution to "unscientific debate" on the issue of whether formula milk should be made available at food banks shouldn't go unanswered. She massively oversimplifies a complex issue when she mentions the charity Feed's statement on …

4 May 2021

Disharmony over talk of an AI piano tutor

From Ros Groves, Watford, Hertfordshire, UK

You report on the possible use of AI to improve piano playing ( 30 January, p 15 ). It appears to focus on assessing a performer's skill in playing the correct notes with the correct rhythms. In doing so, there is a real danger that the essence of such music as a form of emotional …

4 May 2021

More worries about the risk of disease spillover (1)

From Roger Myers, London, UK

Your leader and the associated feature "Spillover" ( p 41 ) appear to lay the blame for the pandemic primarily on our destruction of biodiversity and encroachment on fragile ecosystems Leader, 6 March . Yet for most of human evolutionary history, people have lived within such ecosystems in small groups as hunter-gathers and would surely …

4 May 2021

More worries about the risk of disease spillover (2)

From Fiona Tomley and Dirk Pfeiffer, GCRF One Health Poultry Hub, Hatfield, Hertfordshire, UK

We agree with your article on the problem of pathogens spilling over from animals to humans as we encroach on nature. There is another big factor influencing zoonotic disease emergence, though: the intensification of food animal production. Escalating demand for animal protein means the density of livestock systems is increasingly high. Consequences include pollution, monoculture …

4 May 2021

Extended mask wearing will hamper the recovery

From Bryan Simmons, Bratton, Wiltshire, UK

Those of us who wear glasses can suffer badly from lenses steaming up while wearing a face mask 6 March, p 10 . It is a nuisance when doing something necessary like shopping. Given the talk of masks being required until 2022, I certainly wouldn't pay to go to a concert, the theatre or a …

4 May 2021

Reduce and reuse is the only plastic bottle remedy

From Shenali Kalawana, London, UK

You reported research that found 2.3-litre plastic bottles are the least harmful to the planet 6 March, p 23 . But why advocate an optimum size at all? We shouldn't create loopholes for the production of harmful plastic products. The best way to prevent harm is to reduce use of plastic bottles and switch to …

4 May 2021

For some, exercise is the key to keeping weight off

From Guy Cox, St Albans, New South Wales, Australia

My own experience differs from some of the claims in Herman Pontzer's article on human metabolism, particularly the lack of weight loss caused by exercise 27 February, p 32 . In my teens, I took up running. When my children were of school age, I had less time to run and I really put on …

4 May 2021

Spin a yarn in the battle against garden slugs

From Mike Starke, Chale Green, Isle of Wight, UK

Here is a tip for Clare Wilson to keep the slugs at bay 27 February, p 49 . My wife grows crop after crop of pristine green beans. Her secret is to pack pieces of hand-spun fleece yarn around the bean stems. This has successfully deterred the gastropods from adding her Phaseolus vulgaris to their …

4 May 2021

For the record

In our report on life found underground ( 27 February, p 14 ), we should have said the deepest previously known life was microscopic nematode worms. It is the sun's increasing energy that will warm Earth in the far future ( 6 March, p 12 ).

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop