Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


27 November 2019

Hypnosis may be suffering from mentalist reputation

From Stefan Badham, Portsmouth, Hampshire, UK

Reading Helen Thomson's interesting and amusing article on hypnosis, I wondered if hypnotists aren't taken seriously because, historically, they claimed to be using only their minds to do it ( 9 November, p 34 ). As Thomson reports, anaesthetist Aurore Marcou uses local anaesthetics and mild sedation in modern, medical-based hypnosis, making the hypnotist one …

27 November 2019

Neglected concerns about the nutrient choline

From Marloes Schaap, Utrecht, The Netherlands

With Clare Wilson's article on the neglected nutrient choline, you present a diagram showing beef liver as an important source of it ( 26 October, p 20 ). As Wilson reports, some research suggests that women should have more choline when they are pregnant. But pregnant women are advised to avoid liver of any kind, …

27 November 2019

Little figures on the ceiling explained by science

From Hillary Shaw, Newport, Shropshire, UK

You mention the camera obscura as an example of unconventional imaging ( 9 November, p 42 ). I saw a camera obscura after moving into a house with high ceilings, tall windows and a short front garden. On a bright first morning, I saw tiny figures moving on the ceiling. The folds at the top …

27 November 2019

Tackling the puzzle of low-carbon domestic energy (1)

From Jeremy Hawkes, Liverpool, UK

As Adam Vaughan says, gas boilers are a UK election battleground, with three of the main parties wanting to phase them out, each at a different rate ( 9 November, p 18 ). But methane is a great biofuel that is relatively easy to make, store and transport. Sensibly, three times more UK domestic energy …

27 November 2019

Recycling heat to save energy in our home

From Patrick Davey, Dublin, Ireland

Matthew Allan proposes that we retrofit homes with integrated heat-handling equipment ( Letters , 26 October ). This is a great idea. We already have a sealed house. Its controlled ventilation incorporates a heat exchanger working at 92 per cent efficiency. The only heat we waste is water from washing machines and showers. These use …

27 November 2019

One spoonful of tea avoids plenty of plastic problems

From Paul Whiteley, Bittaford, Devon, UK

You report the pollution and possible health risks of plastic particles from teabags ( 5 October, p 16 ). There is a simple way to avoid these: stop using teabags. For the price of a box of teabags that makes 25 cups, I buy loose tea to make 250 cups.

4 December 2019

We have a model of global climate cooperation now

From Austin Woods, London, UK

You ask us to imagine an international research institution dedicated to climate change, bringing together "the best minds from climate science, energy technology, economics, social science and beyond" (Leader, 23 November ). The European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts , based in Reading, UK, is an international institution supported by 34 states. It employs around …

4 December 2019

Tree planting is something we can do for the climate

From Adam Osen, Harlow, Essex, UK

Your article on ways of removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere was fascinating ( 10 August, p 18 ). Options included bioenergy, carbon capture and storage and sequestration of carbon in the soil. The only one on your list that ordinary people can do is to plant trees. But how effective is this? An average …

4 December 2019

We are rather sceptical of this 'helical engine' (1)

From Rory Allen, York, UK

David Burns's idea for a "helical engine" with no propellant is ingenious ( 19 October, p 15 ). He imagines a movable ring, whose mass is much greater when it slides in one direction than the other. But transferring energy to the ring to increase its velocity and hence, by the rules of relativity, its …

4 December 2019

We are rather sceptical of this 'helical engine' (2)

From Tony Blake, Adelaide, Australia

It looks hard to find any fault with Burns's design for propulsion without a propellant , but centuries of experience tell us that, in all attempts to get around the conservation of energy, an increase in energy somewhere is always balanced by an exactly equal decrease somewhere else. My guess is that this proposal will …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop