Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


11 September 2019

Editor's pick: Health apps need to be a regulated public good

From Alan Taman, Birmingham, UK

I was encouraged to read that the National Health Service in England is taking the need to develop IT-based healthcare seriously ( 24 August, p 9 ). Clare Wilson's report rightly pointed out the need for companies developing IT with therapeutic or diagnostic aims to consider evidence-based development as paramount to patient safety and effectiveness. …

11 September 2019

Classifying dementia may help find treatments

From Bob Kahn, Warrington, Cheshire, UK

It is true that cancer kills far more people in the UK than dementia, as Clare Wilson reports ( 17 August, p 10 ). But the many different types of cancer can be readily identified. Dementia is much less clearly defined and it has many side effects, such as falls and pneumonia. Researchers at University …

11 September 2019

For the record – 14 September 2019

• The eruption that caused a mini ice age in the 6th century AD was somewhere in the northern hemisphere ( 31 August, p 14 ). • Waggle room: male drone bees have only one set of chromosomes ( 17 August, p 38 ). • Ouch. Many gallstones are composed of cholesterol and crystals of …

18 September 2019

Money can't buy you happiness or contentment

From Ros Groves, Watford, Hertfordshire, UK

Apparently, the search for happiness is now a well-funded industry ( 31 August, p 30 ). Surely this calls into question whether spending so much time, money and, quite possibly, anxiety in its pursuit is counter-productive. Instead, wouldn't it be better to question what exactly happiness is? To me, it is experienced in response to …

18 September 2019

Maybe grandchildren, not children, make us happier

From Brian Horton, West Launceston, Tasmania, Australia

Alice Klein reports that having children makes us happier, but only when they leave home ( 24 August, p 12 ). This is consistent with a previous study ( 5 September 2015, p 40 ) showing that parents over 40 were happier than younger parents. I suggested (Letters, 26 September 2015 ) that it is …

18 September 2019

Please find a lower-impact kind of random curiosity

From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK

You suggest readers download a computer program to search for Mersenne primes in the background ( 10 August, p 38 ). Yet every week you report the looming peril of climate change and the need to change our behaviour to limit it. Modern laptops and many desktop computers throttle back the processor speed and put …

18 September 2019

Neanderthals' ears could indicate an aquatic past

From Malcolm Knight, Frizington, Cumbria, UK

Neanderthals' ears show signs of time in the water, as Ruby Prosser Scully reports ( 24 August, p 17 ). This seems to lend credence to the idea that humans led a semi-aquatic lifestyle, possibly before the split between Neanderthals and Homo sapiens. Wading for fish and shellfish could have driven development of long hind …

18 September 2019

Why can't we use seawater to make hydrogen?

From Albert Lightfoot, Albury, New South Wales, Australia

As Chris deSilva says, exporting hydrogen produced by electrolysis is like exporting water (Letters, 20 July ). But why use fresh water? Pure water is essentially a non-conductor, while seawater conducts electricity, aiding electrolysis. It may also have useful by-products, such as industrially useful rare earth metals, cobalt and lithium. If some desalination is necessary, …

18 September 2019

Lord make me admit my ignorance, but not yet

From Mark Tester, Burtonsville, Maryland, US

According to Anna Ijjas, Saint Augustine is said to have quipped that prior to creating the universe, God was preparing hell for those who pry into mysteries ( 17 August, p 42 ). What he in fact wrote in Confessions is: "I answer the man who says, 'What did God do before he made heaven …

18 September 2019

For the record - 21 September 2019

• The photo illustrating our note about the kakapo population hitting 200 was of a different parrot (31 August, p 21). • We loathe vans (and other vehicles) spitting out nitrogen oxides ( 7 September, p 42 ).

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop