Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


16 April 2019

Editor's pick: It's past time for ordinary climate solutions

From David Flint, London, UK

Adam Vaughan reports measures we could take to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from transport ( 30 March, p 23 ). As he says, they will not be enough. That's because one thing is missing: panic. Academics and policy wonks are still talking as if we are facing an ordinary problem, like stagnant productivity. We are …

16 April 2019

First class post – 20 April 2019

It's not just polar bears breeding with grizzlies: humans also interbred with others Alice Outwater could be more surprised at Homo sapiens interbreeding relatively recently with Denisovans ( 6 April, p 9 )

16 April 2019

Population replacement may have been different (1)

From Cathryn Iliffe, Bradford, West Yorkshire, UK

Colin Barras reports work on the spread of Yamnaya culture from the Eurasian steppes ( 30 March, p 29 ). In the UK, the people who built Stonehenge probably left a genetic legacy. Studies show an influx of DNA from 2450 BC, after which Yamnaya DNA varied from 60 to 100 per cent between individuals. …

16 April 2019

Ask the goldilocks planet: it doesn't care (1)

From Philip Bolt, Kirriemuir, Angus, UK

I was interested to read about evolution by persistence and its connection to the Gaia hypothesis of a self-regulating planet ( 23 March, p 34 ). It got me thinking about a crucial part of the theory. Gaia doesn't care. There is a danger that some people reading the article will take comfort in the …

16 April 2019

Ask the goldilocks planet: it doesn't care (2)

From David Ashton, Sheringham, Norfolk, UK

Isn't the most remarkable fact about the evolutionary process that, by means of the human brain on this planet, the "universe" is asking questions about its own existence?

16 April 2019

Could Neanderthals have farmed these rabbits?

From Ralph Reid, Coolamon, New South Wales, Australia

You suggest that the absence of infant rabbit bones at Neanderthal sites means that rabbits were hunted individually rather than flushed from burrows ( 16 March, p 20 ). It is also possible that rabbits were raised in captivity and harvested only as adults. I am sure that the Neanderthals were smart enough to cotton …

16 April 2019

Greens with a side of poisonous arsenic

From Aidan Karley, Brechin, Angus, UK

So a species of caterpillar happily dines on arsenic-loaded leaves ( 16 March, p 20 ). I recall how a suggestion that microbes could substitute arsenic for phosphorus in their biochemistry ( 26 April 2008, p 10 ) caused a mild furore and then rebuttals ( 28 January 2012, p 6 ). Wouldn't such caterpillars …

16 April 2019

For the record – 20 April 2019

• However it may be discovered that functional disorders arise, there is no suggestion that it is through conscious thinking ( 6 April, p 28 ). • The philosopher Daniel Dennett popularised the word "sphexish" to describe rigidly-determined behaviours, but did not coin it ( 6 April, p 34 ).

24 April 2019

When order arises and when it fights back (1)

From Malcolm Shute, La Tour d'Aigues, France

Thank you for the feature on the possibility of selection by persistence ( 23 March, p 34 ). It is true that whenever a system, whether a saucepan of water on a flame or a planet orbiting a star, is agitated by a flux of energy, it is inevitable that structures will form ( 21 …

24 April 2019

When order arises and when it fights back (2)

From Ann McAvoy, Greystones, County Wicklow, Ireland

I am glad that the Gaia hypothesis is being revisited, as it can explain a lot. If the planet is seeking stability, human activities such as rising carbon dioxide levels and pollution of the oceans challenge this. As a result of climate change, we now have floods, fires and the spread of disease, all of …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop