Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


17 October 2018

Editor's pick: For mammals, matriarchy is second nature

From Thelma Rowell, Ingleton, North Yorkshire, UK

Chelsea Whyte reports that in only seven species of mammal do females exhibit leadership ( 29 September, p 8 ). Leadership is a difficult concept to apply to animals, and indeed different definitions seem to be applied in each of the seven species cited. I cannot offhand think of any species of large long-lived social …

17 October 2018

First class post – 20 October 2018

I feel safer with the pilot having the same outcome as me! @wotsapnin isn't quite ready for the driverless aircraft of the future ( 6 October, p 42 ) .

17 October 2018

Are milk alternatives really the white stuff?

From Adam Croucher, London, UK

Thank you for Chelsea Whyte's article on milk alternatives ( 22 September, p 22 ). It is high time that the question about the ecological and health impact of "alt-milks" is addressed in more detail – please write more! The perceived benefits and harms of these "milks" have been left to marketing and the fashions …

17 October 2018

For the record – 20 October 2018

• The data artist with whom Hannah Redler-Hawes co-curated the LMAO exhibition is Julie Freeman ( 29 September, p 44 ). • Estimates of the number killed by Allied bombing raids on Germany in 1939-45 are in the hundreds of thousands ( 6 October, p 16 ).

24 October 2018

What other substitutions are found in alt-milks?

From Paul Whiteley, Bittaford, Devon, UK

Chelsea Whyte lists alternatives to cow's milk ( 22 September, p 22 ). Potential convertees should be cautious as not all alternatives are what they seem, with price not necessarily being a helpful guide. Soya milk can contain as little as 5 per cent soya beans. The best I've seen in the UK is 12 …

24 October 2018

Shrimp's breakout punch doesn't hold water

From Rob Gunnett, London, UK

You describe a mantis shrimp that "creates a force that shatters aquarium glass" ( 29 September, p 40 ). This is simply not true. I'm a senior aquarium service technician with over 25 years of experience, and this is one of those stories that gets tossed around, yet there's no actual proof of it ever …

24 October 2018

The silent majority are going to the polls

From David Cole, Dunmow, Essex, UK

Simon Oxenham repeats the standard New Scientist suggestion that a liberal outlook is the default in Western societies and that, conversely, a current propensity for conservatives to support right-wing "populist" parties is pathological ( 15 September, p 24 ). His assertion that higher voter turnouts may lead back to "a more familiar political landscape" is …

24 October 2018

Unexamined legacy of the Vietnam conflict

From Ian Kennedy, Norwich, UK

Andy Coghlan writes that the bombs dropped in the second world war rattled the edge of space ( 6 October, p 16 ). The total bomb load dropped on Vietnam in the mid 1960s and early 1970s was some three times that dropped on Europe over a similar timescale. One would expect a similar reduction …

24 October 2018

Wipe out malaria, but keep the mosquitoes

From Christopher Clark, Houston, Texas, US

Simon Terry and Stephanie Howard raise the ethics around deliberately causing extinctions, with the example of mosquitoes that infect people with malaria being genetically engineered to spread sterility in their species ( 13 October, p 24 ). Couldn't we instead engineer a mosquito not to carry the plasmodium that causes malaria? That would still allow …

24 October 2018

The nose knows, but what about us?

From Harry Lake, Bussum, The Netherlands

Alastair Mouat writes that the head brewer at his Edinburgh brewery could distinguish between the same canned beer produced at different locations ( Letters, 15 September ). How does he know the head brewer wasn't having them all on?

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop