Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


4 July 2018

Capture that carbon where it's easy to get at

From Christopher Jessop, Marloes, Pembrokeshire, UK

Let us hope that the process to produce hydrocarbons by feeding carbon dioxide to artificial enzymes can be scaled up economically ( 2 June, p 17 ). Presumably it will be "powered" by low-grade heat. It would be perfect to site such a facility next to a brewery, winery, distillery or pharmaceutical plant. All these …

4 July 2018

Disposal is the central issue with plastic bags

From Constance Lever-Tracy, Adelaide, South Australia

I was surprised to read you suggesting that plastic bags might do more environmental damage than cotton ones (Leader, 16 June ). For me, the primary and most urgent objection to plastic is not so much in its production but in the enormous and harmful effects of its waste, which (unlike cotton) survives and accumulates …

4 July 2018

Being pitch perfect isn't much help to a musician

From Georg Pedersen, Sydney, Australia

You quote musician Rick Beato saying that perfect pitch is "a tremendous advantage" ( 9 June, p 14 ). But what all musicians need is relative pitch – that is, accurate perception of the intervals between notes. If a musician's absolute pitch does not conform to the actual pitch of the instruments they are playing …

11 July 2018

What drove Australia's mammals into the night?

From Tony Power, Artarmon, New South Wales, Australia

Michael Le Page reports that wild animals are turning nocturnal to keep away from humans ( 23 June, p 14 ). I have often pondered why modern Australian mammals are mostly nocturnal. Was there an ancient daytime predator that drove them into the night? Candidates could include thylacoleos (marsupial lions), dromornithids (demon ducks of doom) …

11 July 2018

Stone Age sailors could have used bamboo rafts

From John Morris, Avoca Beach, New South Wales, Australia

Colin Barras's interesting article on ancient sailors raised doubts about the suitability of bamboo for building rafts ( 2 June, p 36 ). He says freshly cut bamboo is not suitably light and buoyant, and dried bamboo too tough to work. When I was a surveyor in Papua in the 1950s, I noticed that people …

11 July 2018

Would aliens want to learn to speak dolphin? (1)

From Cedric Griffiths, Perth, Western Australia

Douglas Vakoch asks what form of language we should use to send messages to aliens ( 9 June, p 22 ). I have no idea – but dolphins, whales or birds may have. Perhaps we should be sending recordings of their communications into space as well as human sounds. We could also put as much …

11 July 2018

Would aliens want to learn to speak dolphin? (2)

From John Bailey, Farnborough, Hampshire, UK

Someone needs to caution Douglas Vakoch that he does not hold a democratic mandate to broadcast humanity's existence to potential threats. Some may scoff about the vast distances, but I am sure the Incas and Aztecs would have felt that Madrid was a long way away. The editor writes: • All the same, the argument …

11 July 2018

Spacefaring must be cooperative and peaceful (2)

From Marc Smith-Evans, Bagabag, Nueva Vizcaya, Philippines

I read your Leader and other space news with sadness. In the 58 years since humanity first ventured into space, it is still mainly explored competitively. There is cooperation in the European Space Agency and International Space Station, but the narrative is, on the whole, nationalistic or militaristic. Donald Trump's proclamation of a US Space …

11 July 2018

The captain spells out the price of virtual war

From David Smith, Corfe Mullen, Dorset, UK

John Phillips suggests that war could be fought in the virtual world (Letters, 9 June ). In a 1967 episode of Star Trek titled " A Taste of Armageddon ", our heroes encounter civilisations engaged in virtual war. Having decided that this is meaningless if there are no real-world consequences, at regular intervals the parties …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop